Renewals that don't just happen to you

How contractors prepare for insurance renewal: the 120-day timeline, what underwriters look at, fleet risk, and deductibles vs. premium.

Every renewal sets a big piece of your cost of risk for the next twelve months. Premium is a line item that comes straight out of net operating income, and so are the deductibles, the claims you keep and the hours your office spends chasing paperwork.

Most contractors experience renewal as something that happens to them. A quote shows up about 30 days out, it's higher, and there's a week to decide. That isn't shopping. It's reacting.

This section covers the other way to do it: start early, make your case to the underwriter with proof, decide what you keep and what you hand off on purpose, and treat your fleet as the risk it is. Every dollar you take out of the cost of risk at renewal goes straight to NOI.

Underwriters price your file, not your company

An underwriter never walks your jobsites. They see forms, loss runs, your experience mod and whatever else lands on their desk. Two companies with the same trade, size and loss history can get very different prices because one sent forms and the other sent forms plus a clear story with proof.

Carriers can credit a well-run company, but only for what they can see. Good companies shouldn't be priced like average ones just because nobody told their story.

Read the full guide

The real renewal work starts 120 days out

Count back from your renewal date. Around 120 days out, order fresh loss runs from every carrier. Around 100 days out, get your mod worksheet and check it for mistakes. Around 90 days out, the submission goes out. Underwriter conversations, quotes and the final decision follow from there, with binding about a week before the policy starts.

The simplest way to say it: the price you see at 45 days out is decided by what arrived at 90 days out. If you want to understand the mod piece first, start with how the experience mod works.

Commercial auto is where the system shows

Ask contractors which renewal gives them the most heartburn and many will say auto. You can't change the market, but you can change what a carrier sees when they look at your fleet.

Trucks aren't only an auto risk. When your own employee is hurt in a crash while driving for work, that is usually a workers' comp claim too, and motor vehicle claims are among the most expensive comp claims there are. Four controls matter most: who gets to drive, who takes trucks home, telematics only when someone acts on the data, and a written fleet policy every driver signs.

Read the full guide

What you keep and what you hand off

Every insurance decision is some version of one choice: keep the risk (retention) or pay someone else to carry it (transfer). Deductibles, self-insured retentions and choosing not to insure something are all ways of keeping risk.

Keeping more lowers premium, but the cost doesn't disappear. It moves into the claims you pay yourself. That's why a deductible can never be judged by premium alone, and why your deductibles should fit the company you run now, not the one you started.

Read the full guide

Compare quotes on coverage, not only price

Two quotes with different prices are rarely the same product. Before you pick one, compare the limits, the exclusions, the deductibles, and whether the additional insured and waiver terms match what your contracts require. In Arizona, also check whether the carrier is admitted or surplus lines, which carries a 3% tax.

The cheapest quote that leaves a gap in a contract you signed isn't cheap. For more on what your contracts ask for, see contract insurance requirements.

Proof is what turns a story into a price

"We take safety seriously" means nothing on an underwriter's desk. Dated training records, a written injury reporting rule, a sub certificate process that's actually followed, a signed fleet policy and short signed reports of finished safety work do.

In a Frost program, every finished task gets a short report signed by both the owner and the advisor, and only what a document proves gets called a saving. Those reports become the backbone of the next submission. Here's more on why savings need proof.

Quick answers

When should I start preparing for my insurance renewal?

About 120 days before your renewal date, starting with fresh loss runs from every carrier. Underwriters generally want loss runs valued within about 90 days of when the submission goes out.

Will a better submission guarantee a lower premium?

No. Nobody can control the market or promise a price. A complete, honest submission with proof gives the underwriter reasons to credit your company that they can't see otherwise.

Should I raise my deductibles to lower my premium?

Not without your own numbers. Keeping more risk only makes sense when the premium saved is more than the losses you expect to pay yourself plus any collateral cost, and your company can absorb a bad year.

Does Frost sell or place insurance?

No. Frost is software. Brokers and risk advisors use it to run a contractor's risk program all year. Your insurance is still placed and serviced by your broker.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent