How to prepare an insurance renewal submission underwriters can credit

Underwriters don't price your company. They price your file. Here's what goes in it, and why the real work starts 120 days out.

Picture an underwriter's desk, 90 days before your renewal.

Two files are sitting on it. Same trade. Same size. Same loss history.

The first file is forms and a loss report.

The second has the same forms, plus two pages: who the company is, what happened with last year's claims, what changed afterward with dates, and signed reports of finished safety work.

Which one would you price better?

Here's the hard part. The owner of the first file doesn't even know the renewal has started. He'll find out at 30 days, when the quote shows up higher.

Underwriters don't price your company. They price your file.

What do underwriters actually look at?

  • Your experience mod
  • Your loss history, and how losses compare to premium over time
  • How complete and clear your submission is
  • Any reason to believe your company is getting better, or worse

That last one is where good companies leave money on the table. Carriers can credit a well-run company. But they can only credit what they can see.

Good companies shouldn't be priced like average ones just because nobody told their story.

What renewal feels like at 30 days

If you've been the first file, you know the feeling. The quote arrives. It's up. You get a week to decide. Every option feels like the same option.

If your renewal process starts at 30 days, you're not shopping. You're reacting.

The 120-day renewal timeline

Here's a rhythm that works. Count back from your renewal date.

  • 120 days out: Pull fresh loss runs from every carrier. Underwriters want loss runs valued within about 90 days of when your submission goes out, and stale ones slow everything down.
  • 100 days out: Get your mod worksheet and check it for mistakes.
  • 90 days out: The submission goes out. This is the big one.
  • 60 days out: Meetings or calls with underwriters, so they hear your story from a person, not just a form.
  • 45 days out: Quotes come back and get compared.
  • 30 days out: The decision: which quote, which coverage, which deductible.
  • 7 days out: Bind.

The simplest way to say it: the price at 45 days out is decided by what arrived at 90 days out.

How do I write a renewal narrative?

The second file had two extra pages. Here's what was on them.

  • Who are you? What kind of work, what size, how long in business?
  • What happened? If there were claims, what caused them and what changed afterward?
  • What are you doing now? Safety work, training, sub checks, reporting rules.
  • What's next? The plan for the coming year, with owners.

Honest beats polished. If you had a rough year, say so, and show what you did about it. An underwriter would rather see a company that learned something than one pretending nothing happened.

And never put anything untrue in a submission. Not a number, not a claim, not a program you don't actually run.

Proof, not adjectives

"We take safety seriously" is something every company says. It means nothing on a desk.

What means something:

In a Frost program, every finished task gets a short report signed by both the owner and the advisor. Those reports become the backbone of the story. Finished work is described as finished. Plans are described as plans. Only what's been proven gets called a saving.

The rule is simple: if it isn't written down, it didn't happen.

How should I compare renewal quotes?

When the quotes come in, price matters. But two quotes with different prices are rarely the same product. Compare:

The cheapest quote that leaves a gap in a contract you signed isn't cheap.

Who owns the renewal clock?

A 120-day timeline only works if someone owns it. In most companies, nobody does. The office, the broker and the carriers each wait on the others, and the owner hears about it at 30 days. Name one person on your team to own the timeline with your broker.

Give the renewal a name. One seat orders the loss runs, checks the mod worksheet, gathers the proof and keeps the story current through the year, not just in the month before it's due. When the person in that seat changes, the seat and its due dates stay.

That's the difference between a renewal that happens to you and one you run.

What's at stake

Stay the first file, and the renewal keeps happening to you. Another higher number. Another week to decide.

Become the second file, and you walk into renewal with a story you can explain and proof to back it. From reacting to a price to making your case.

Try this

Find your renewal date. Count back 120 days. Put that date on your calendar with one task: "Order loss runs."

Then start a one-page document called "Our story." Write three sentences: who you are, what changed this year and what you're working on next.

Where to start

Ask your broker to start the 120-day timeline with you and to show you what a carrier sees today. From there, a Baseline adds up what risk really costs you, and a 90-day plan puts an owner and a date on every task, with signed proof of every saving that becomes the proof in your next submission. Approved Frost agents run this kind of program for contractors, start to finish.

Quick answers

What are loss runs?

Loss runs are reports from your insurance carriers listing the claims on your policies and what was paid or reserved. Underwriters generally want them valued within about 90 days of when your submission goes out.

How far ahead of renewal should my submission go to underwriters?

About 90 days before the renewal date. Getting there means ordering loss runs around 120 days out and checking your mod worksheet around 100 days out.

Should I mention a bad claim year in my submission?

Yes. The underwriter will see the losses anyway. Explain what caused them and what changed afterward, with dates and proof, and never include anything untrue.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent