Picture this.
It's October. The workers' comp renewal lands on an owner's desk.
The experience mod reads 1.18. Last year it was 0.96.
Nothing bad happened this year. Nobody got hurt. The crews worked clean.
So where did that number come from? It came from two and three years ago. The mod remembers.
What is the experience mod?
The experience mod compares your company to other companies doing the same kind of work.
The rating bureau (NCCI, in Arizona and most states) looks at your payroll and your type of work and figures what your losses should have been. Then it compares that to what they actually were.
- 1.00 means you're right at the expected level
- Below 1.00 means you did better, and you pay less
- Above 1.00 means you did worse, and you pay more
Here's where it becomes real money. Every 0.01 of mod moves your manual premium by about 1%. Manual premium is the starting price for workers' comp, before other credits and discounts.
So the owner in our picture just watched his mod climb 22 points. That's about 22% more on the starting price than a year ago. Same work. Same payroll. Different history.
And every dollar of that surcharge comes out of net operating income.
How long does one claim stay on your mod?
The mod looks backward. It uses three completed policy years, ending one year before the new policy starts.
So a claim doesn't hit your price right away. It shows up at the second renewal after the policy year it happened in. Then it stays for three renewals in a row.
Put plainly: one injury on a job site this fall can still be shaping your price four years from now.
That's the part that stings. The owner opening that renewal isn't being priced on the company he runs today. He's being priced on the company he ran three years ago.
It's a hard way to lead. You're paying for a scoreboard you can't see, written in a language nobody taught you.
You shouldn't need a risk department to understand your own price.
Why do small claims hurt more than one big one?
This surprises most owners.
The mod is built so that how often people get hurt matters more than how big any one claim is. The first part of every claim counts in full. Only part of a large claim counts.
Here's an illustration I use in training. It's not a real company.
- Five claims of $20,000 each produced a mod of 1.373.
- One claim of $100,000 produced a mod of 0.947.
Same total dollars. Very different price.
So go back to our owner. If his 1.18 came from a string of small claims three years ago, the strains, the cuts, the "it's nothing" injuries, that's exactly how the mod is designed to read them.
Count claims before you count dollars.
Where does the mod come from?
Your mod comes from a worksheet NCCI produces. It lists your payroll, your claims and the math, line by line.
Nobody guesses it. Not your agent, not your carrier. Frost doesn't calculate your official mod either. It takes the number straight off the worksheet.
Frost's founder spent years in IT and cybersecurity before insurance. The rule there was simple: trust the log, not the story. The worksheet is the log.
What can an owner actually change?
You can't change the formula. You can change what goes into it.
- Frequency. Fewer claims is the biggest lever. It starts with new hires: 44% of construction injuries happened to workers in their first year on the job, and those injuries drove 47% of construction workers' comp claim costs (Travelers 2026 Injury Impact Report). More on that in first-year worker risk.
- Reporting speed. Claims reported in week 3 or later cost about 35% more than ones reported in week 2 (NCCI). Higher claim costs flow onto the worksheet. See the first 72 hours of a claim.
- Return to work. Claims with no lost time, called medical-only claims, typically count at a reduced share on the worksheet. Light duty can help keep a claim medical-only.
- Open claims. An open claim counts at what's been paid plus the carrier's reserve. Ask where every open claim stands well before renewal.
- Accuracy. Worksheets are built from records, and records can be wrong. Check the payroll and claims against yours.
Every item on that list is something your company does. Not something your insurance does.
What nobody should promise
Nobody should promise you a mod number by a date.
Nobody honest can. Your mod depends on your losses, your payroll, NCCI's factors and the calendar. The safety work you do today shows up at the renewal after next. Mod savings are a Year 2 story, not a Year 1 story.
What a good advisor can do is help you work the inputs, then show you the worksheet when it moves. That worksheet is the proof.
What's at stake
Leave it alone, and the pattern repeats. A few "small" claims this year become a higher price for three renewals in a row.
Work it on purpose, and something changes. You open the renewal and you already know the number. You know which claims are on it and the year each one rolls off.
From getting surprised by a number to reading it.
Try this
- Get a copy of your current mod worksheet. It's yours. Your agent or carrier can send it.
- Circle every claim on it and count them.
- Next to each one, write how many days it took to report, whether it is still open, and whether the person came back on light duty.
That one page will teach you more about your workers' comp price than any quote.
Where to start
Ask your broker for your current mod worksheet and the prior two. From there, a Baseline adds up what risk really costs you, mod included, and a 90-day plan puts an owner and a date on every task, with signed proof of every saving. Approved Frost agents run this kind of program for contractors, start to finish.
The reference entries behind this page: definitions, the math and the sources.
The NCCI experience rating worksheetHow insurance premium is builtThe experience mod formulaWhat moves the experience modThe frequency–severity matrixTRIR and DART rates explainedBrowse the whole Library →Quick answers
What is a good experience mod for a contractor?
A 1.00 mod means your losses match what NCCI expected for your payroll and type of work. Below 1.00 is better than expected and lowers your manual premium; above 1.00 raises it.
How many years does a claim stay on my experience mod?
The mod uses three completed policy years, ending one year before the new policy starts. A claim typically first appears at the second renewal after it happened and stays for three renewals.
Can my agent or Frost calculate my mod?
No. Your mod comes from the worksheet NCCI produces. Frost takes the number straight off that worksheet and does not calculate it. What Frost adds is the arithmetic behind it: it re-checks the worksheet row by row and shows what each claim added, so you can see what moves it.