Loss forecasting and the loss pick

In short

A loss pick is the estimate of next year's expected losses, built from your past claims. The method develops each past year to ultimate, adjusts it to today's costs, divides by exposure such as payroll to get a rate, selects one rate with a stated reason, and multiplies it by next year's projected exposure.

Every financing decision about a contractor's losses rests on one estimate: how much will next year's claims cost? Underwriters and actuaries call their answer the loss pick, also known as expected losses. It drives the price of loss-sensitive programs, the size of a sensible deductible, and whether keeping risk is cheaper than insuring it.

What is a loss pick?

A loss pick is a forecast of one future year's losses on one line, built from several years of past losses, typically about five. It is usually stated ground-up: every dollar of every expected claim, before deciding how much falls inside a deductible and how much the carrier pays. That is deliberate. The pick measures the whole problem first, and the retention decision splits it afterward.

How is a loss pick built?

The method has five steps, and each one removes a bias from raw loss-run figures.

  1. Develop each year to ultimate. Multiply each policy year's current incurred by the loss development factor for its age. This removes the age bias: young years look cheap because their claims are still growing.
  2. Trend each year to the forecast year (optional). Losses from three years ago were paid at older wage and medical prices. A trend rate moves each year's ultimate to the coming year's cost level: trended = ultimate × (1 + trend) raised to the number of years between. Use one only when you can name its source.
  3. Divide by exposure. Exposure is what losses grow with: payroll for workers' comp, sales for general liability, vehicles for auto. Dividing gives a rate, such as dollars of loss per $100 of payroll. This removes the size bias, so a $2,000,000 payroll year and a $2,500,000 payroll year can be compared fairly.
  4. Select a rate. Look at the series of rates and choose one. The average is the anchor. Moving above or below it needs a stated reason: a safety control that is clearly working, a one-off claim in an old year, a change in the kind of work.
  5. Multiply by next year's exposure. Loss pick = selected rate × projected exposure ÷ 100.

A worked example

Illustrative numbers for a contractor's workers' comp, three policy years, no trend applied.

Developed ultimates (from the triangle in the loss development entry):

  • Year A, 36 months old: $126,000 on payroll of $2,000,000
  • Year B, 24 months old: $115,500 on payroll of $2,000,000
  • Year C, 12 months old: $96,640 on payroll of $2,500,000

Rates per $100 of payroll:

  • Year A: 126,000 ÷ 2,000,000 × 100 = $6.30
  • Year B: 115,500 ÷ 2,000,000 × 100 = $5.78
  • Year C: 96,640 ÷ 2,500,000 × 100 = $3.87
  • Average: (6.30 + 5.78 + 3.87) ÷ 3 = $5.32

The rates are falling, and the newest year is lowest even after development. A reasonable selection is $5.00: below the $5.32 average because the trend is down and a minor-injury program has been running since Year C began, but above $3.87 because a single young year is thin evidence.

Loss pick for a coming year with projected payroll of $3,000,000:

  • 5.00 × 3,000,000 ÷ 100 = $150,000 of expected ground-up losses.
  • Had the average been used instead: 5.32 × 3,000,000 ÷ 100 = $159,600.

The $9,600 difference is the value of the judgment, and the reason for it should be written down.

What trend does to old years

Suppose a 10% annual trend (illustrative) and a forecast three years after Year A. Year A's $126,000 becomes 126,000 × 1.10 × 1.10 × 1.10 = 126,000 × 1.331 = $167,706. Trend matters most for the oldest years, which is why it should come from a named source, such as wage growth on payroll or an actuary's medical trend, rather than added "to be safe."

Why say it as a rate?

The rate survives growth; the dollar figure does not. "Your workers' comp losses run about $5 per $100 of payroll" stays true when payroll goes from $3,000,000 to $4,000,000, and it lets the owner compare against the premium and rating on the same base. It also makes payroll accuracy matter: the exposure numbers should match the payroll reported by class code.

How is the loss pick used?

  • Retention decisions. The pick is the starting point for comparing guaranteed cost with a deductible or SIR. The share of it that falls inside the retention is the expected retained loss. See retention vs transfer.
  • Loss-sensitive pricing. On large-deductible and retrospectively rated programs, the carrier's premium is built around its own loss pick. A contractor that has done its own forecast knows whether the carrier's figure is a fair estimate or an opening position.
  • Budgeting. A pick turns "we had a bad year" into a planned number the owner and CFO can carry in the budget.

Common mistakes

  • Picking the newest year's rate because it is lowest. It is also the least developed.
  • Forgetting exposure. Without payroll or sales by year, the years cannot be compared.
  • Confusing the pick with developed past losses. Developed losses are the expected final cost of claims that already happened; the pick is next year's claims, which have not.
  • Using one valuation and calling the result ultimate. With no development measured, the pick inherits the loss run's age bias.

A sound pick is one forecast that every later decision uses. The renewal submission guide covers how to present it to underwriters.

Quick answers

What is a loss pick in insurance?

It is an underwriter's or actuary's estimate of one future year's expected losses, based on past loss experience. It is the loss component of loss-sensitive programs such as large deductibles and retrospective rating.

How many years of losses do you need to forecast?

Typically about five years, developed to ultimate, with the exposure for each year. Fewer years can work, but the selection then rests on thinner evidence.

Is the loss pick the same as my premium?

No. The pick is the expected cost of claims; premium adds the carrier's expenses, taxes, profit and the cost of carrying risk above what you retain.

Terms in this entry
Loss pick
An estimate of one future year's expected losses, built from developed past losses and exposure. Also called expected losses.
Loss development factor (LDF)
A multiplier that carries current incurred losses to their expected ultimate cost, measured from how past years grew between valuations.
Retention
Losses a business pays itself, on purpose, through a deductible, a self-insured retention or a budget, usually in exchange for a lower premium.
Sources and standards
  1. Loss pick · IRMI
  2. Estimating Unpaid Claims Using Basic Techniques (Friedland) · Casualty Actuarial Society
  3. Loss development factor · IRMI

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
Retention and loss financingLoss development factors (LDFs) explainedA loss development factor (LDF) is a multiplier that carries today's incurred losses to their expected final, or ultimate, cost.Retention and loss financingRetention vs transfer: choosing what to keepRetention means paying some losses yourself, through a deductible, SIR or budget; transfer means paying a carrier or another party to carry them.The insurance programHow insurance premium is builtA commercial insurance premium is a chain of steps: exposure times rate gives the manual premium, which is then adjusted by the experience mod, schedule credits or debits, and a premium discount, before flat charges, fees and taxes are added.Workers' comp and the experience modWorkers' comp class codes and payrollWorkers' comp premium starts with payroll sorted into class codes, each describing a kind of work with its own rate per $100 of payroll.Retention and loss financingLoss runs: how to read oneA loss run is your insurance carrier's claim-by-claim history for a policy: each claim's dates, status, amount paid and amount still reserved, all as of one valuation date.Resources · 5 min guideHow to prepare an insurance renewal submission underwriters can creditUnderwriters don't price your company. They price your file. Here's what goes in it, and why the real work starts 120 days out.Resources · 5 min guideDeductibles, retention and transfer: what to keep, what to insureEvery risk ends up in one of two places: you keep it or you hand it off. Here's how to decide where the line sits.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent