Deductibles vs self-insured retentions

In short

Under a deductible, the insurance carrier handles and pays the whole claim, then bills you back for your share. Under a self-insured retention (SIR), you pay and handle the claim yourself until the retention is used up, and only then does the policy respond. Both lower the premium; both make your own losses part of your cost.

Every insurance program decides who pays the first dollars of a claim. A contractor can hand that job entirely to the carrier, or keep part of it in exchange for a lower premium. The part you keep is called a retention: losses you pay yourself, on purpose. The two most common ways to structure it are the deductible and the self-insured retention. They sound alike and both shrink the premium, but they work differently when a claim actually lands.

What is a deductible?

A deductible is the first part of an insured claim that you agree to pay. On liability and workers' comp policies, the carrier usually adjusts the claim and pays it in full, then sends you a bill for the deductible amount. On property, the deductible is simply subtracted from what the carrier pays you.

The key point is that the carrier stays in charge. Its adjusters investigate, set the reserve (their estimate of what the claim will still cost), hire defense counsel and settle. You fund your share after the fact.

A large-deductible program is a workers' comp or liability policy with a per-claim deductible in the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars. Because the carrier is paying first and collecting later, it is exposed if you cannot pay the bill. So it asks for collateral: security held against deductible amounts it has paid or expects to pay but has not yet collected. A letter of credit from your bank is the most common form; cash, trusts and bonds are others. Actuaries generally size it from the estimated unpaid losses inside the deductible, adjusted for the buyer's financial strength. Many large-deductible programs also include an aggregate, a cap on the total deductible payments you can owe for the year.

What is a self-insured retention?

A self-insured retention (SIR) is the amount you pay before the policy responds at all. Below the retention, there is no insurance for that claim: you (usually through a third-party administrator, or TPA, that you hire for a fee) investigate, defend and pay. Once the retention is used up, the carrier's coverage begins above it.

Because the carrier owes nothing until the retention is exhausted, it generally does not need collateral the way a deductible carrier does. It will, however, want proof you can pay, and it usually requires notice when a claim's reserve gets close to the retention.

SIRs are common on umbrella and excess liability policies and on larger general liability programs. A workers' comp retention that replaces insurance altogether is a different thing: legal self-insurance, which the state regulates. In Arizona, A.R.S. 23-961 lets an employer pay comp directly only with Industrial Commission approval and satisfactory proof of financial ability, and the Commission may require a deposit or other security of not less than $100,000.

How do they compare on the same claim?

Take one general liability claim that settles for $80,000, including defense costs (illustrative numbers):

  • With a $25,000 deductible: the carrier handles the claim and pays the full $80,000. It then bills you $25,000. Your cost is $25,000; the carrier's net is 80,000 − 25,000 = $55,000.
  • With a $25,000 SIR: you, or your TPA, handle the claim and pay the first $25,000. The carrier pays the remaining 80,000 − 25,000 = $55,000.

The dollars split the same way. What differs is everything around them:

  • Who controls the claim. Deductible: the carrier. SIR: you or your TPA, until the retention is reached.
  • Who fronts the cash. Deductible: the carrier, then bills you. SIR: you, as the claim is paid.
  • Collateral. Large deductibles usually require it; SIRs generally do not.
  • Policy limits. A deductible payment usually counts against the policy's aggregate limit. An SIR usually sits below the limit and does not reduce it.
  • Handling cost. Under an SIR you pay the TPA. Under a deductible the carrier's handling is typically built into the premium or billed per claim.

Which one costs less?

Neither, in the abstract. Moving from a guaranteed-cost policy (the carrier pays every claim and your cost is the premium) to either structure trades a known premium for an unknown amount of retained loss. The honest comparison adds four things together: the premium, the expected retained losses, the yearly cost of any collateral, and claim handling fees. A premium decrease shown without the retained losses it bought is half a number.

That math, and the worst-case year that goes with it, is the subject of retention vs transfer. The expected retained losses come from a loss pick built on your own claims, not from the deductible amount itself.

What should an owner check before choosing?

  • Whether the retention applies per claim, per occurrence or per year, and whether an aggregate caps it.
  • Whether defense costs count toward the deductible or SIR, or are paid on top of it.
  • How much collateral is required, in what form, and what your bank charges for it each year. A letter of credit also uses up borrowing capacity you might want for payroll.
  • Under an SIR, who will handle claims and what that costs.
  • Whether contracts require you to name others as additional insureds, and how an SIR affects them. Some project owners object to SIRs because their defense would start with you, not a carrier.

The decision turns on how predictable your losses are and how strong your balance sheet is. A contractor that reports injuries fast, manages claims closely and has steady losses is being paid, through the premium credit, to be good at that. One that is not will pay for it in retained losses. The practical guide to deductibles and retention walks through the conversation with your carrier. On contract wording or financial statements, talk to your attorney and CPA.

Quick answers

Is a self-insured retention the same as a deductible?

No. Under a deductible the carrier pays and handles the claim, then bills you back. Under an SIR you pay and handle the claim until the retention is used up, and only then does the policy respond.

Why does my carrier want a letter of credit for a large deductible?

Because the carrier pays claims first and collects your deductible later, it is exposed if you cannot pay. The letter of credit is security against deductible amounts it has paid or expects to pay but has not yet collected.

Can a contractor self-insure workers' comp in Arizona?

Only with approval from the Industrial Commission of Arizona under A.R.S. 23-961, which requires proof of financial ability to pay and may require security of at least $100,000. Most contractors use a deductible instead; talk to your attorney and CPA before pursuing self-insurance.

Terms in this entry
Retention
Losses a business pays itself, on purpose, through a deductible, a self-insured retention or a budget, usually in exchange for a lower premium.
Deductible
The first part of an insured claim the policyholder pays. On liability and workers' comp the carrier usually pays the claim in full and bills the deductible back.
Self-insured retention (SIR)
An amount the insured pays and handles itself before the policy responds at all. Coverage applies only above the retention.
Large-deductible program
A workers' comp or liability policy with a per-claim deductible in the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars, usually requiring collateral.
Collateral (letter of credit)
Security, most often a bank letter of credit, that a carrier holds against deductible amounts it has paid or expects to pay but has not yet collected.
Guaranteed cost
A policy with no meaningful retention: the carrier pays the claims and the policyholder's cost is the premium.
Aggregate stop
A cap on the total retained losses a policyholder can owe in a policy year under a deductible or retention program.
Sources and standards
  1. Self-insured retention (SIR) · IRMI
  2. Self-Insured Retentions versus Deductibles · IRMI
  3. Large deductible programs: Demystifying collateral · Milliman
  4. A.R.S. 23-961, Securing compensation; self-insurance · Arizona State Legislature

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent