A commercial insurance premium is a chain of steps: exposure times rate gives the manual premium, which is then adjusted by the experience mod, schedule credits or debits, and a premium discount, before flat charges, fees and taxes are added. Rates are not the buyer's to move, but exposure accuracy, the mod and documented safety work are.
A premium is not one number an underwriter picks. It is a chain of multiplications and additions, and each step has a name. Workers' comp shows the chain most clearly, so this entry builds a workers' comp premium from the bottom. General liability, auto and property follow the same shape with different exposures.
What goes into a premium?
- Exposure times rate. The exposure is what the premium is measured on: payroll for workers' comp, payroll or revenue for general liability, vehicles for auto, values for property. The rate is the price per unit of exposure. For workers' comp, payroll in each class code (the category for the kind of work) is divided by 100 and multiplied by that class's rate. The total is the manual premium, the price before anything about this particular business is considered.
- Experience mod. The experience modification factor compares the business's own losses over a three-year window with what is expected for a business of its size and type. 1.00 is average, 1.15 means 15% more than average, 0.90 means 10% less. It multiplies the whole manual premium.
- Schedule rating. A schedule credit or debit is a percentage the underwriter applies for things the mod does not capture, such as safety programs, supervision, equipment and management. It must be documented and stays within limits in the carrier's filing. On general liability the same idea is often called IRPM, individual risk premium modification.
- Premium discount. Larger workers' comp premiums get a volume discount on the portion above a threshold.
- Flat charges. An expense constant (a flat per-policy charge), terrorism and catastrophe charges, and state assessments. None of these depend on the buyer's record.
- Fees and taxes on top. Policy fees, broker fees, and, when the policy is placed in the surplus lines market, a state tax and a stamping fee. See broker compensation, fees and taxes.
Who sets the rate?
Rates come from a rating organization and the carrier. A rating bureau collects premium and loss data across the market and files advisory rates or loss costs with regulators. For workers' comp, that bureau in Arizona and most states is the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI). Each year the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions reviews NCCI's filing; for policies effective Jan 1, 2026, that filing lowered Arizona workers' comp rates by 6.7% on average. For general liability and auto, the Insurance Services Office (ISO) plays the bureau role, and each carrier adjusts from there.
The rate is the one step a contractor cannot change. Everything around it can be influenced.
A worked example: building a workers' comp premium
Illustrative numbers. The class names, rates, credit and constant below are chosen to teach; real ones come from the policy's rating page and the NCCI class schedule.
- Field carpentry: $2,000,000 payroll ÷ 100 × $6.00 = $120,000
- Clerical office: $400,000 ÷ 100 × $0.50 = $2,000
- Supervisors and estimators: $600,000 ÷ 100 × $1.50 = $9,000
- Manual premium: 120,000 + 2,000 + 9,000 = $131,000
- Experience mod 1.15: 131,000 × 1.15 = $150,650
- Schedule credit of 5%: 150,650 × 0.95 = $143,117.50
- Expense constant of $250: 143,117.50 + 250 = $143,367.50, then any assessments and terrorism charge shown on the policy
The mod alone added 131,000 × 0.15 = $19,650. The schedule credit took back 150,650 × 5% = $7,532.50.
Class codes matter just as much. If $200,000 of clerical payroll had been reported under field carpentry, it would cost 200,000 ÷ 100 × (6.00 − 0.50) = $11,000 too much before the mod, and 11,000 × 1.15 = $12,650 after it.
What can a contractor actually change?
- Exposure accuracy, this year. Payroll in the right class, revenue estimated honestly, subcontractor certificates on file before the audit. See workers' comp class codes and payroll.
- The mod, over three years. Fewer and smaller claims, managed well, lower the mod, and the mod multiplies the whole manual premium. See the experience mod formula.
- Schedule credits, at renewal. These are the underwriter's call, but they depend on evidence. A safety program that exists on paper and in practice, shown with data, gives the underwriter a reason to credit.
What cannot be moved: the rate, the premium discount schedule, the expense constant and assessments.
How do you read a rating worksheet?
Find the manual premium first. Everything above it is exposure and rate. Everything below it is the business's own record and the underwriter's judgment. The gap between the manual premium and the final premium is what the company's loss history and safety evidence are costing or earning it.
A common error is applying a mod change to the final premium instead of the manual premium. With a final premium of $180,000 and a mod of 1.15, the manual premium is about 180,000 ÷ 1.15 = $156,521.74, so each 0.01 of mod is worth about $1,565, not $1,800. This shortcut ignores the expense constant and discount, so use the actual worksheet for exact figures. This is the number a Frost program is built around: the part of premium the contractor's own behavior controls.
The renewal submission guide shows how to put that evidence in front of underwriters.
Quick answers
How is workers' comp premium calculated?
Payroll in each class code is divided by 100 and multiplied by that class's rate, giving the manual premium. That is multiplied by the experience mod, adjusted by any schedule credit or debit and premium discount, and then flat charges such as the expense constant are added.
What is a schedule credit?
A percentage reduction an underwriter applies for documented strengths the experience mod does not capture, such as safety programs or supervision. It is discretionary and limited by the carrier's filing; on general liability it is often called IRPM.
Can a contractor lower its insurance rates?
Not the base rate, which comes from the rating bureau and carrier. A contractor can lower premium through accurate payroll classification, a better experience mod over time, documented safety work that earns schedule credits, and clean audits.
- Manual premium
- The premium from exposure times rate, before any adjustment for the business's own loss record or underwriter judgment. For workers' comp it is payroll in each class divided by 100, times that class's rate, summed.
- Schedule credit or debit
- A percentage an underwriter subtracts from or adds to premium for documented risk features the experience mod does not capture, within limits in the carrier's filing. On general liability it is often called IRPM.
- Expense constant
- A flat charge added to every workers' comp policy to cover fixed administrative costs. It does not depend on payroll or loss history.
- Experience mod (EMR)
- A multiplier on workers' comp premium comparing your actual losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for your size and class mix. 1.00 is average; above it is a debit, below it a credit.
- Class code
- A numbered workers' comp classification describing a type of work, each with its own rate per $100 of payroll. In Arizona the classification system comes from NCCI.
- Rating bureau (definition) · IRMI
- Schedule rating (definition) · IRMI
- Expense constant (definition) · IRMI
- Experience rating (definition) · IRMI
- Workers' Compensation Rates Decrease for a 12th Consecutive Year · NICB (republishing Arizona DIFI announcement)
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.