New hires and turnover: the people side of risk
How new hires and turnover drive the cost of risk for contracting companies, and how a 90-day onboarding plan protects net operating income.
Most contractors think about risk as a line on the insurance bill. But look at where the cost of risk actually comes from, and you keep landing on the same place: people.
Who you hire, how you bring them on, and how long they stay drive your injuries, your claims, your workers' comp premium and the hours your supervisors lose to all of it. That's usually the biggest cost driver in the whole picture.
Every dollar you take out of the cost of risk goes straight to net operating income. This hub covers the people side: new hires, turnover, and the simple measures that show whether it's getting better.
Why people drive the cost of risk
Your workers' comp premium is built on payroll. Your claims come from the people doing the work. And the hidden costs of an injury, like lost time, a slowed crew and a supervisor filling out reports, all run through people too.
Construction injuries average 114 missed workdays, the longest of any industry studied (Travelers 2026 Injury Impact Report). That's months of a seat sitting empty or filled by someone new.
So when you work on the people side, you aren't working on an HR project. You're working on the biggest lever you have over the hidden cost of risk.
The first year is the most dangerous stretch
44% of construction injuries happened to workers in their first year on the job, and those injuries drove 47% of construction workers' comp claim costs (Travelers 2026 Injury Impact Report, 1.2 million+ claims, 2021 to 2025).
The people with the least experience and the least confidence to speak up carry close to half the injuries and close to half the claim costs. Most of it comes from small gaps: they don't know the site yet, they don't want to look slow, and training happens "as we go."
The fix is treating the first 90 days as their own phase, with a plan, a mentor by name and a few numbers you track every quarter.
Turnover is a cost of risk
Owners say the same thing almost every week: "We can't find enough good people." Every time a good person leaves, the seat gets filled by someone new, and that someone is a first-year worker starting the clock over.
Turnover also pulls supervisors off the job to train, breaks up crews before they find a rhythm, and walks safety habits out the door. None of that shows up on an insurance quote. All of it shows up in your cost of risk.
Seats, not people
A seat is a role, not a person. People change. The seat and its responsibilities stay.
In a good risk plan, every responsibility belongs to a seat: Owner, Safety lead, Superintendent, Office manager, Fleet, Claims contact. When the person in a seat leaves, the work stays written down and someone new can pick it up. That's how a plan survives turnover at the top. See how it fits on a one-page risk plan.
Three numbers to watch
You can't manage what you don't measure. These three tell you most of what you need to know about the people side of risk:
- First-year injuries, including first aid, as a share of all injuries
- New hires still with you at 90 days
- New hires still with you at 12 months
Track them every quarter, next to your cost of risk per $1,000 of revenue. If the first number is high and the other two are low, onboarding is costing you twice.
Why this is personal: 30x4
I grew up with a single mom. Life sometimes felt impossible, but I always had someone in my corner. Many young adults aging out of foster care don't. They're ready to work, but they often don't have a door, a path up or people around them when life outside work gets heavy.
At the same time, contractors need good people who stay. 30x4 is the vision I'm building toward to connect those two needs: a national network of 30 leaders in contracting, each generating about 30 career starts a year at $30,000 or more, about 900 careers and $30 million in annual wages, fully rolled out by 2030. Employers bring the job, the training and the path up. Nonprofit partners help with housing, transportation, mentoring and documents. It's measured on retention, advancement and wage growth, not on how many people got hired.
To be honest about where it stands: it's a vision in its early days. I'm building the first relationships with employers and nonprofit partners now, the same way I build everything, with a plan, owners and proof. Learn about 30x4 — Brandon Junkin, founder of Frost
The reference entries behind this page: definitions, the math and the sources.
Indirect cost of workplace injuriesReturn-to-work programs for contractorsTRIR and DART rates explainedWorkers' comp class codes and payrollHeat illness prevention in ArizonaOSHA recordkeeping and the 300 logBrowse the whole Library →Guides in this topic
Quick answers
Why do new hires get hurt more often?
They don't know the site, the hazards or who to ask yet, and many don't want to look slow by asking. Per the Travelers 2026 Injury Impact Report, 44% of construction injuries happened to workers in their first year on the job.
Is turnover really an insurance issue?
It's a cost of risk issue. Every person who leaves is usually replaced by a first-year worker, and first-year workers carry a large share of injuries and claim costs.
What should I measure first?
Start with first-year injuries as a share of all injuries, and how many new hires are still with you at 90 days and at 12 months. Track them quarterly.
What is 30x4?
A national vision for young adults aging out of foster care: 30 leaders in contracting, each generating about 30 career starts a year at $30,000 or more, fully rolled out by 2030. It's in its early days, and I'm building the first relationships with employers and nonprofit partners now.
Want this run for your company?
Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.