Workers' comp and your experience mod

How the experience mod works for contractors, why small claims hurt, and the claim habits that lower workers' comp costs and raise net operating income.

Workers' comp is one of the biggest lines in the cost of risk for most contractors. It is also one of the few you can move from the inside.

Every dollar you take out of what workers' comp really costs you, premium, the mod surcharge, the hours lost to an injury, goes straight to net operating income. Same revenue. More of it kept.

The catch is that the price runs on a scoreboard most owners never see. This page walks through how that scoreboard works and the handful of things your company does that change it.

What is the experience mod?

The experience mod compares your company's actual workers' comp losses to what the rating bureau expected for a company with your payroll and type of work. In Arizona and most states, that bureau is NCCI.

A 1.00 mod is average. Below 1.00, you pay less. Above 1.00, you pay more. Each 0.01 of mod moves your manual premium, the starting price before other credits, by about 1%.

The mod looks backward at three completed policy years, so one claim can shape your price for three renewals in a row. Your mod comes from the NCCI worksheet, line by line. Nobody guesses it, and Frost doesn't calculate it either. It takes the number straight off the worksheet.

Read the full guide

Why do small claims hurt the mod so much?

The mod is built so that how often people get hurt matters more than how big any one claim is. The first part of every claim counts in full. Only part of a large claim counts.

That means a string of "it's nothing" injuries, the strains and cuts, can push a mod higher than one serious claim with the same total dollars. Count claims before you count dollars.

Frequency starts with new hires: 44% of construction injuries happened to workers in their first year on the job (Travelers 2026 Injury Impact Report). See first-year worker risk for that side of the story.

How fast should a claim be reported?

Fast, and the same way every time. NCCI found that claims reported in week 3 or later cost about 35% more than claims reported in week 2. Higher claim costs flow onto the worksheet.

Speed is only half of it. The Workers Compensation Research Institute (WCRI) found that when an attorney gets involved, a claim pays about $7,700 to $12,400 more in wage-replacement benefits. A same-day phone call from someone at the company is one of the simplest ways to keep a worker from wondering whose side you're on.

Read the full guide

What does return to work have to do with cost?

When an injured worker can't work, workers' comp pays part of their wages for the days they miss. Those payments are called indemnity. Every day a worker is back, even on light duty, is a day of payments that doesn't happen.

Claims with no lost time, called medical-only claims, typically count at a reduced share on the mod worksheet. Light duty can help keep a claim medical-only.

Return to work only works if the light-duty jobs exist before you need them. Write a short modified-duty job list now, with the physical demands of each task, so a doctor can match a job to the restrictions. The first 72 hours guide shows how.

Why do open claims and reserves matter?

When a claim is still open, the carrier sets aside a reserve: its estimate of what the claim will cost before it closes. On your worksheet, an open claim is counted at what has been paid plus that reserve, not just what has been paid so far.

So an open claim with a high reserve can weigh on your mod even if the worker is back and the bills have slowed down. Claims are valued on a set date before your renewal, and whatever the reserve says on that date is what the worksheet uses.

Ask for your loss runs well before renewal. For every open claim, ask the adjuster where it stands, whether the reserve still fits the facts, and what it would take to close. You can't set the reserve. You can make sure someone is asking about it.

Who owns workers' comp inside your company?

If the answer is "everybody," nobody does. In a Frost risk plan, there is a seat called the claims contact. That seat owns the reporting clock, the same-day call, the return-to-work plan and the open-claim follow-up. The superintendent owns how fast injuries get reported from the field.

Every lever on this page is something your company does, not something your insurance does. A named owner and a due date turn those levers into a plan. Start by getting a copy of your current mod worksheet and counting the claims on it. Then read how the experience mod works.

Quick answers

Can I get my experience mod lowered this year?

Usually not this year. The mod looks back at three completed policy years ending one year before your policy starts, so work you do today shows up at the renewal after next. Anyone who promises a mod number by a date is guessing.

Where do I get my mod worksheet?

It is produced by NCCI in Arizona and most states. Your agent or carrier can send you a copy, and it belongs to you.

Does reporting a claim quickly make my mod go up?

The claim is on the worksheet either way. Fast reporting is tied to lower costs: NCCI found claims reported in week 3 or later cost about 35% more than ones reported in week 2.

What is a medical-only claim?

A claim where the worker needed treatment but missed no paid time from work. These typically count at a reduced share on the mod worksheet, which is one reason light duty matters.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent