Deductibles, retention and transfer: what to keep, what to insure

Every risk ends up in one of two places: you keep it or you hand it off. Here's how to decide where the line sits.

Picture an owner cleaning out the office. He pulls the policies out of a drawer and reads the deductibles for the first time in years.

Some came with the very first quote, back when the company had two trucks and one crew. Some came with whatever the last renewal offered.

He asks himself a simple question: "Who picked these?"

Nobody did. Not really.

Every risk ends up in one of two places

Either you keep it, or you hand it off.

Every insurance decision you make is some version of that choice. Most owners have just never been asked to make it on purpose.

What is the difference between retention and transfer?

Retention means the risk you keep. When something goes wrong, you pay for it.

Transfer means the risk you hand off. You pay someone else, usually an insurance company, to pay for it instead. You can also transfer risk through contracts, like when your subs carry insurance that protects you. More on that in contract insurance requirements.

Most companies do both. The question is where the line sits.

Deductible vs. self-insured retention vs. uninsured

There are three common ways to keep risk.

  • A deductible. The insurance company handles the claim, and you pay the first part, up to your deductible. Sometimes the carrier pays the whole claim and bills you back for your share.
  • A self-insured retention (SIR). You pay the first part yourself, and you often handle that part of the claim too. The insurance company steps in only after you've paid your share.
  • Uninsured. You don't buy coverage for that risk at all. If it happens, it's all yours.

Each one moves a little more of the risk, and the work, onto your side of the table.

Does a higher deductible save money?

When you keep more risk, premium goes down. You're asking the insurance company to do less.

But the cost didn't disappear. It moved. Some of what you used to pay in premium you now pay in claims.

That's why you can never judge a deductible by premium alone. Raising it lowers what you pay for transfer and raises what you keep. You have to measure them as a pair, as part of your total cost of risk.

Back to the owner at the drawer. Deductibles from the first quote were set for a company with two trucks. His company today might be insuring small, predictable losses it could easily pay itself. Or it might be keeping a risk that would hurt badly in a rough year.

He doesn't know which. That's the uncomfortable part: decisions that move real money every year, and no one in the building owns them.

Your deductibles should fit the company you run now, not the one you started.

The principle behind keeping more risk

Here's the rule, in one sentence.

Keeping more risk makes sense when the premium you save is more than the losses you expect to pay yourself, plus the cost of any collateral the carrier asks you to post.

Collateral is money or a letter of credit a carrier may require when you keep a bigger share of the risk, to make sure you can pay your part. It ties up cash, and that has a cost too.

One more test doesn't fit in a formula: can your company absorb a bad year? A deductible that looks smart on average can hurt in the year you have three claims instead of one.

One question sits under all of it, the same one Frost's founder asked business owners for years when he sold website security before insurance: what can this business afford to absorb, and what does it need to protect? It's the same question here. Just bigger numbers.

What this is not

This is not a recommendation to raise your deductibles.

Every company's answer is different. It depends on your claim history, your cash, your lenders, your contracts and how your losses tend to develop over time. Making this choice without your actual numbers is guessing.

A change like this should only happen after a real review of the deductible against the premium, using your own loss history. And it gets decided at renewal, with time to think, not the week before you bind. The 120-day renewal timeline leaves room for exactly that.

Questions to ask before you change a deductible

Before you move the line in either direction, get answers to these:

  • What have our losses under this deductible looked like over the last several years?
  • How much premium does the change actually save?
  • Would the carrier want collateral, and what would that cash cost us?
  • Could we pay three claims at this level in one bad year?
  • Do our lenders or contracts limit how much risk we can keep?

If you can't answer them yet, you're not ready to change the number. You're ready to start measuring it.

What's at stake

Leave it in the drawer, and you might be paying extra every year for losses you could easily carry. Or carrying a risk that could sink a good year.

Decide it on purpose, and the line sits where your company can actually hold it.

What you keep. What you hand off. Why. That's a renewal you can explain.

Try this

Pull your current policies and write one line for each:

  • The policy
  • The deductible or retention on it
  • Who chose that number, and when

If the last answer is "I'm not sure," you just found a good conversation for your next renewal.

Where to start

Ask your broker to walk through what you keep and what you hand off today. From there, a Baseline adds up what risk really costs you, the part you transfer and the part you keep, and a 90-day plan puts an owner and a date on every task, with signed proof of every saving. Approved Frost agents run this kind of program for contractors, start to finish.

Quick answers

What is a self-insured retention?

A self-insured retention (SIR) is an amount you pay yourself, and often handle yourself, before the insurance company steps in. With a deductible, the carrier usually handles the claim and you pay or reimburse your share.

Why might a carrier ask for collateral?

When you keep a bigger share of the risk, a carrier may require money or a letter of credit to make sure you can pay your part. That ties up cash, which is a real cost to weigh.

Should every contractor raise their deductibles?

No. The right level depends on your claim history, cash, lenders, contracts and how your losses develop. It should be decided with your own loss history, not by premium alone.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent