Subcontractor prequalification

In short

Subcontractor prequalification is the process a general contractor uses to confirm, before a sub is hired, that it is licensed, insured, safe and financially able to do the work. It is the control that makes the rest of subcontractor risk transfer work, because a certificate, an endorsement or an indemnity promise is only as good as the sub standing behind it. Arizona is the worked example; the rule in your state may differ.

Subcontractor prequalification is the review a general contractor completes before a subcontractor is allowed to bid or start work: Is the sub licensed? Insured on the terms the contract requires? Safe? Able to finish the job and pay its bills? It is a risk control technique, an action taken before a loss to make losses less likely or less costly, and it is the control that makes contractual risk transfer hold up.

Certificates, additional insured endorsements and indemnity clauses all assume a sub with a real insurer and a real business behind it. Prequalification is where you find out whether that is true.

Why does a sub's risk become the contractor's risk?

Three mechanisms move a sub's problems onto the general contractor.

  • Workers' comp. Under A.R.S. 23-902, when a business keeps supervision or control over work that is part of its own trade, the workers of contractors and subcontractors doing that work are treated as the business's employees for workers' comp purposes. An uninsured sub's injured worker can become the general contractor's claim, and that claim can sit in the contractor's experience mod for three years.
  • Premium audit. Payments to subs without proof of workers' comp coverage are typically charged as the contractor's own payroll at its class rate, times its mod.
  • OSHA. OSHA's multi-employer citation policy (CPL 02-00-124) allows citations on multi-employer sites not only to the employer that created a hazard or whose workers were exposed, but also to the employer with general supervisory authority over the site, the controlling employer, which is often the general contractor.

What does subcontractor prequalification check?

A solid prequalification file covers six areas:

  1. License. A.R.S. 32-1151 makes it unlawful to act as a contractor in Arizona without a license in good standing, unless an exemption applies. Confirm the license number, classification and status with the Arizona Registrar of Contractors.
  2. Insurance. A current certificate of insurance plus the endorsements the subcontract requires: additional insured for ongoing and completed operations, primary and noncontributory, and waivers of subrogation. Check for excluded officers on workers' comp and for exclusions that would leave the sub's work uncovered.
  3. Safety record. The sub's experience mod, its OSHA 300A summaries for recent years, its recordable and lost-time rates, and any OSHA citations.
  4. Safety program. A written program that fits the work, training records, and who supervises on site.
  5. Financial capacity. Bonding capacity or references, years in business and current backlog, enough to judge whether the sub can finish and still honor an indemnity promise.
  6. Experience. Similar projects, references from other general contractors.

Then repeat the insurance check whenever a job runs past a sub's policy renewal, and hold payment until a current certificate arrives.

A worked example: the low bid after audit (illustrative numbers)

Two framing subs bid the same scope.

  • Sub A bids $410,000. It is licensed, carries workers' comp, and supplies a valid certificate with the required endorsements.
  • Sub B bids $395,000. It is licensed but cannot produce workers' comp coverage, and it invoices in lump sums.

The general contractor's workers' comp rate for the class the auditor applies is $8.00 per $100 of payroll, and its mod is 1.15.

  1. Sub B's payments charged as payroll at audit: $395,000.
  2. Additional premium: $395,000 / 100 x $8.00 x 1.15 = $36,340.
  3. Sub B's true cost: $395,000 + $36,340 = $431,340.

The "cheaper" bid costs $21,340 more than Sub A before anyone is hurt. If one of Sub B's workers is injured, the claim can also land on the contractor's policy and mod.

How do contractors make prequalification stick?

  • One rule. No complete file, no start; no current certificate, no payment.
  • One owner. Usually the office manager or project administrator, not the field.
  • One measure. Compliance as a share of sub spend, not a count of subs. Fully compliant spend divided by total sub spend, with a target of 100%.
  • One review cycle. Re-score subs after each job and drop or coach the ones with incidents.

Underwriters ask about subcontractor controls on the application and price uninsured sub exposure. A contractor that can show its prequalification file and compliance rate at renewal is answering a question before it is asked.

What your subcontract requires is your attorney's call. For the routine that keeps the file current, see the subcontractors guide.

Quick answers

What should a subcontractor prequalification form include?

License status, insurance certificates and endorsements, experience mod and OSHA 300A history, a written safety program, financial capacity or bonding, and references. The insurance items should be re-checked at every policy renewal.

Can a general contractor be responsible for an uninsured subcontractor's injured worker in Arizona?

It can. A.R.S. 23-902 treats workers of contractors and subcontractors as the employer's own for workers' comp purposes when the employer keeps supervision or control over work that is part of its trade. Talk to your attorney about how it applies to a specific arrangement.

How do I check a contractor's license in Arizona?

Search the license number or business name with the Arizona Registrar of Contractors and confirm the classification and status. Arizona law makes contracting without a license in good standing unlawful unless an exemption applies.

Terms in this entry
Subcontractor prequalification
The review a general contractor completes before hiring a sub: license, insurance and endorsements, safety record, safety program, financial capacity and experience.
Statutory employer
A business the law treats as the employer of a contractor's or subcontractor's workers for workers' comp. In Arizona the rule is A.R.S. § 23-902(B).
Certificate of insurance (COI)
A one-page summary, usually on the ACORD 25 form, that shows a policyholder's insurers, policy numbers, dates and limits. It is evidence of coverage on the day it was issued, not a policy, and it grants the holder no rights.
Experience mod (EMR)
A multiplier on workers' comp premium comparing your actual losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for your size and class mix. 1.00 is average; above it is a debit, below it a credit.
Sources and standards
  1. A.R.S. 23-902, Employers subject to workers' compensation; independent contractors · Arizona State Legislature
  2. A.R.S. 32-1151, Contracting without a license · Arizona State Legislature
  3. CPL 02-00-124, Multi-Employer Citation Policy · OSHA
  4. ACORD 25 Certificate of Liability Insurance (2016/03), blank form · National Park Service (hosting the ACORD form)

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
Contracts and subcontractorsCertificates of insurance (ACORD 25)A certificate of insurance (COI) is a one-page summary, usually on the ACORD 25 form, that a subcontractor's insurance agent issues to show what liability and workers' comp policies the sub carries.Contracts and subcontractorsAdditional insured endorsementsAn additional insured endorsement adds another party, such as a general contractor or owner, to a subcontractor's general liability policy for claims arising from the sub's work.Workers' comp and the experience modThe experience mod formulaThe experience mod compares a contractor's actual workers' comp losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for its size and class mix.Workers' comp and the experience modThe workers' comp premium auditA workers' comp policy is priced on estimated payroll and settled after it ends by a premium audit of actual payroll by class code.The risk management processRisk control techniques and risk financingRisk control techniques change the loss itself: avoidance, loss prevention, loss reduction, separation, duplication and diversification.Resources · topicSubcontractors, contracts and certificates of insuranceSubs, certificates and the contracts you sign can quietly cost you money long after a job closes. Learn what the paperwork really proves and how to give it one owner.Resources · 5 min guideSubcontractor certificates of insurance and what they don't proveA certificate looks like proof, but it's only a snapshot. Here's what it shows, what it doesn't and a simple system so lapsed sub coverage never lands on your audit.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent