Risk control techniques and risk financing

In short

Risk control techniques change the loss itself: avoidance, loss prevention, loss reduction, separation, duplication and diversification. Risk financing techniques decide who pays for the losses that still happen: retention or transfer. Control first, then finance what is left.

What are risk management techniques?

Step 3 of the risk management process asks which techniques could treat each loss exposure. The Institutes split the answers into two families.

  • Risk control techniques change the loss itself: how often it happens or how bad it gets.
  • Risk financing techniques decide who pays for the losses that still happen.

There are six of the first and two of the second. Every decision a contractor makes about risk is one of these eight moves, or a mix of them.

What are the six risk control techniques?

  1. Avoidance. Stop the activity that creates the exposure, so the chance of loss drops to zero. Examples: decline demolition work, refuse a contract with a broad-form indemnity clause, stop self-performing crane lifts. Avoidance is a scope decision, and it gives up the revenue too.
  2. Loss prevention. Make losses happen less often. This works on frequency. Examples: orientation before the first shift, weekly site inspections, a driver selection standard, fall protection.
  3. Loss reduction. Make a loss that does happen cost less. This works on severity. Examples: reporting injuries within days, a return-to-work program with modified duty, sprinklers, keeping medical-only claims from becoming lost-time claims.
  4. Separation. Spread assets or operations so one event cannot take them all, with each part in active use. Examples: equipment stored at two yards, materials delivered in stages rather than all at once.
  5. Duplication. Keep an idle backup ready to replace what is lost. Examples: backed-up estimating files, a second lumber supplier on standby, a spare machine at the yard.
  6. Diversification. Spread activity across customers, markets or services so one setback cannot sink the business. Examples: working for three general contractors instead of one, adding service work alongside new construction.

What are the two risk financing techniques?

  • Retention. The business pays for the loss itself, ideally on purpose: inside a deductible, a self-insured retention or a budget line. See deductibles vs. self-insured retentions.
  • Transfer. The business moves the financial burden to someone else. It has two forms worth keeping apart. Insurance transfers the loss to a carrier for a premium. Contractual transfer pushes it to another party by contract: an indemnity clause, an additional insured endorsement or a waiver of subrogation required of subcontractors.

A contractor with excellent policies and no subcontract requirements is retaining every subcontractor loss it cannot push back. Contractual transfer is as much a part of the program as the policies are.

A worked example (illustrative numbers)

Expected loss is frequency times severity: how many losses a year, times the average cost of one. Suppose a contractor has lifting strains at 6 claims a year averaging $5,000. The figures are illustrative.

  • No action: 6 × $5,000 = $30,000 a year of expected loss.
  • Loss prevention halves the count (lifting training, orientation): 3 × $5,000 = $15,000.
  • Loss reduction cuts the average by 20% (faster reporting, modified duty): 6 × $4,000 = $24,000.
  • Both together: 3 × $4,000 = $12,000.
  • Transfer (insure it): still 6 × $5,000 = $30,000 of loss. The carrier pays it, and charges a premium built on it plus its own expenses.
  • Retention (keep it inside a deductible): still $30,000 of loss. The contractor pays it and keeps the premium the carrier would have charged for it.

The point is the shape, not the specific percentages. Control techniques change the $30,000. Financing techniques change whose $30,000 it is.

Which technique comes first?

Control first, then finance what is left. A loss that does not happen costs nothing to finance, and carriers price a contractor's frequency and severity into the premium and the experience mod anyway. Once controls are in place, the remaining losses are sorted: frequent, small, budgetable losses are usually retained; rare, large losses that would hurt the balance sheet are usually transferred. The frequency–severity matrix draws that sorting as a grid, and retention vs. transfer covers the financing choice in depth.

What mistakes do people make with these techniques?

  • Calling a deductible a control. A deductible is financing. It changes who pays, not how many losses happen or how large they are.
  • Using prevention on a severity problem. Orientation makes falls less likely; it does not make a $60,000 fall smaller. Fast reporting and return to work do that.
  • Treating insurance as the whole plan. Insurance is one technique of eight, and the most expensive way to pay for a frequent, small loss, because the premium includes the carrier's expense and profit on top of the loss itself.
  • Forgetting contractual transfer. Certificates, additional insured status and waivers are transfer techniques, and they only work when someone checks them before the subcontractor starts.

Most real programs combine techniques on the same exposure: prevention to cut the count, reduction to limit the bad ones, retention for the small losses and transfer for the large ones.

Quick answers

What is the difference between loss prevention and loss reduction?

Loss prevention lowers how often losses happen (frequency), such as fall protection and orientation. Loss reduction lowers how much a loss costs once it happens (severity), such as fast injury reporting and return-to-work programs.

Is insurance a risk control technique?

No. Insurance is a risk financing technique, a form of transfer. It changes who pays for a loss, not whether the loss happens or how large it is.

What is the difference between separation and duplication?

Separation splits assets or operations that are all in active use, so one event cannot hit everything. Duplication keeps an idle backup in reserve, ready to replace what is damaged.

Terms in this entry
Risk control
Techniques that change the loss itself: avoidance, loss prevention, loss reduction, separation, duplication and diversification.
Risk financing
Techniques that decide who pays for losses that still happen: retention (the business pays) or transfer (insurance or a contract shifts the cost to someone else).
Loss prevention
A risk control technique that makes losses happen less often. It works on frequency, for example fall protection or orientation before the first shift.
Loss reduction
A risk control technique that makes a loss cost less once it happens. It works on severity, for example fast injury reporting or a return-to-work program.
Expected loss
Frequency times severity: how many losses a year multiplied by the average cost of one. Six $5,000 claims a year is $30,000 of expected loss.
Sources and standards
  1. Risk control techniques and loss mitigation · Open Exam Prep (CPCU study guide)
  2. CPCU 551 excerpt: the risk management process · The Institutes
  3. Risk Management Alternatives: The Risk Management Matrix · Saylor Academy (open textbook)

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent