A workers' comp policy is priced on estimated payroll and settled after it ends by a premium audit of actual payroll by class code. The difference becomes additional premium or a refund. For contractors, most audit surprises come from payroll growth, payroll in the wrong class, and payments to subcontractors who could not prove their own coverage.
What is a workers' comp premium audit?
A workers' comp policy is issued on an estimate. At the start of the term the carrier charges a deposit premium based on the payroll you expect, by class code. After the policy expires, the carrier sends an auditor, a form or a request for records, measures what payroll actually was, and recalculates the premium. That settlement is the premium audit. If actual payroll was higher, you owe additional premium. If it was lower, you receive return premium.
The audit is not a penalty. It is how a premium built on class codes and payroll gets its final number. The price you actually pay for the year is the one on the audit statement, not the one on the declarations page.
What does the auditor look at?
The auditor's job is to apply the rating bureau's payroll rules to your records. Expect requests for:
- Payroll registers and summaries by employee, for the full policy term.
- Federal quarterly payroll returns (Form 941) and state unemployment reports, used to confirm totals.
- Officer and owner payroll, which may be subject to a state minimum and maximum.
- Overtime records, because many states exclude the extra pay for overtime from premium.
- Job descriptions or time records showing which class each employee's payroll belongs to.
- Payments to subcontractors and casual labor, with certificates of insurance for each sub.
The most common findings for contractors are payroll that grew during the year and was never reported, payroll in the wrong class, and uninsured subcontractor payments.
Why do uninsured subcontractors show up as payroll?
Because the law can make you responsible for their workers. Under Arizona's statutory employer rule, A.R.S. § 23-902(B), a business that hires a contractor to do work that is part of its regular trade, and keeps supervision or control over that work, is treated as the employer of the contractor's workers for workers' comp purposes. If that sub has no coverage, your policy is the one that answers when its worker is hurt.
Carriers price that exposure at audit. Payments to a subcontractor who cannot show a valid workers' comp certificate for the period worked are generally added to your payroll in the class for the sub's work. An itemized invoice that separates labor from materials may let the auditor remove the materials share; how much, and on what proof, depends on state rules and the carrier's audit practice, so ask the auditor. The fix is a procedure, not a policy: collect certificates of insurance before work starts, and keep them current. The certificates guide covers how. Whether a sub relationship meets the statute is a legal question; talk to your attorney if it is in doubt.
A worked audit
Illustrative classes, rates and payroll; your rates depend on your state, carrier and year.
The policy was written on these estimates: field carpentry $2,000,000 at $6.00 per $100, clerical $400,000 at $0.50, supervisors $600,000 at $1.50, with an experience mod of 1.15. The auditor finds:
- Field carpentry actually ran $2,300,000. (2,300,000 − 2,000,000) ÷ 100 × 6.00 = $18,000 of manual premium.
- Clerical ran $350,000. (350,000 − 400,000) ÷ 100 × 0.50 = −$250.
- Supervisors unchanged.
- $200,000 was paid to subs with no valid certificate, rated in their class at $8.00 per $100. 200,000 ÷ 100 × 8.00 = $16,000.
- Total manual premium change: 18,000 − 250 + 16,000 = $33,750.
- After the 1.15 mod: 33,750 × 1.15 = $38,812.50 of additional premium.
Read the lines separately. The first is growth: real payroll that, reported mid-term, would have been billed in installments instead of all at once. The fourth is avoidable: with a valid certificate on file for every sub, 16,000 × 1.15 = $18,400 of it would not exist.
How should a contractor prepare for an audit?
- Report significant payroll growth to your broker during the term so the deposit can be adjusted.
- Keep payroll records by class, with time records for anyone who splits field and office work.
- Keep a certificate log for every subcontractor, covering every date worked, and ask subs for invoices that split labor from materials.
- Pull the last audit and compare its findings with this year's records before the auditor arrives.
- Ask for the auditor's worksheet, not just the statement. It lists every sub that was charged and why.
What if I disagree with the audit?
Start with the auditor's worksheet and your records. Most disputes are about class assignment or sub certificates, and both are settled with documents: time records showing the split, certificates that were in force on the dates worked. Your broker can send those to the carrier and request a revised audit.
Audited payroll matters beyond this year's bill. It becomes the payroll behind the expected losses in your future experience mod, so an audit that is wrong today can also skew the mod.
Quick answers
Why did I get a bill after my workers' comp policy ended?
The policy was priced on estimated payroll. The premium audit measured actual payroll by class, and if it was higher, or if uninsured subcontractor payments were added, the difference is billed as additional premium.
Do I pay workers' comp premium on subcontractors?
Not for subs who can show valid workers' comp coverage for the period they worked. Payments to subs without proof of coverage are generally charged as your payroll at audit.
How can I avoid a large workers' comp audit bill?
Report payroll growth during the term, keep payroll records by class, and collect current certificates of insurance from every subcontractor before they start work.
- Premium audit
- The carrier's review of actual payroll by class after a policy ends. It settles the premium as additional premium owed or return premium refunded.
- Statutory employer
- A business the law treats as the employer of a contractor's or subcontractor's workers for workers' comp. In Arizona the rule is A.R.S. § 23-902(B).
- Class code
- A numbered workers' comp classification describing a type of work, each with its own rate per $100 of payroll. In Arizona the classification system comes from NCCI.
- Manual premium
- The premium from exposure times rate, before any adjustment for the business's own loss record or underwriter judgment. For workers' comp it is payroll in each class divided by 100, times that class's rate, summed.
- A.R.S. § 23-902, Employers subject to chapter · Arizona State Legislature
- Heterogeneity of Office and Clerical Classifications · NCCI
- ABCs of Experience Rating · NCCI
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.