Subrogation is an insurer's right, after paying a claim, to recover that money from whoever caused the loss. A waiver of subrogation is an endorsement in which the insurer gives up that right against a named party, such as the general contractor, so a subcontractor's carrier cannot pay its own worker's claim and then sue the contractor to get the money back.
Subrogation is an insurer's right, after it pays a claim, to step into its policyholder's shoes and recover the money from whoever caused the loss. It is fair in general: the party at fault pays in the end. On a job site it creates a problem, because the parties at fault are often the same people who signed a contract agreeing to share the job's risk through insurance.
A waiver of subrogation is a promise that the insurer will not pursue that recovery against a particular party. In contracting, a subcontract usually requires the sub to obtain waivers on its workers' comp, general liability, auto and umbrella policies in favor of the general contractor and the owner. The waiver is made in the contract and carried out by an endorsement on each policy.
How does subrogation work on a job site?
Picture a sub's electrician who falls through an unguarded floor opening. The sub's workers' comp carrier pays the claim: medical bills and lost wages. Workers' comp generally stops the electrician from suing his own employer, but it does not stop his employer's carrier from looking for someone else to blame. If the floor opening was the general contractor's responsibility, the carrier can sue the general contractor to recover what it paid.
That lawsuit lands on the general contractor's own general liability policy. It becomes a claim on the contractor's loss runs, consumes defense costs and can affect the contractor's renewal pricing, even though the contract said the sub's insurance would handle injuries to the sub's people.
What does a waiver of subrogation do?
With a waiver in place, the sub's carrier pays the claim and has no right to recover from the general contractor. The injured worker still receives every benefit he is owed. The waiver changes who absorbs the cost, not whether the claim is paid.
It does not do three things:
- It does not reduce the sub's own claim or the sub's premium.
- It does not stop the injured worker from bringing a separate lawsuit of his own against a third party, where state law allows one. That exposure is what additional insured status and the indemnity clause address.
- It does not protect anyone not named or described in the endorsement.
Which endorsements create the waiver?
Each line of coverage has its own standard form:
- Workers' comp: WC 00 03 13, Waiver of Our Right to Recover From Others. The carrier waives recovery against the party named in the schedule, and only for work done under a written contract that requires it. The form has a premium field, and carriers commonly charge for the waiver.
- General liability: ISO CG 24 04, Waiver of Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us. The current edition is 12 19. It applies to parties named in the schedule, and only to the extent the insured waived its own rights in writing before the loss.
- Auto and umbrella policies have their own waiver endorsements or conditions.
A checked SUBR WVD box on a certificate of insurance is not the waiver. The ACORD 25 itself says a statement on the certificate does not replace the endorsement.
A worked example (illustrative numbers)
A sub's laborer is hurt on a general contractor's job. The sub's workers' comp carrier pays $120,000 in medical and wage benefits. The carrier's investigators conclude the general contractor's missing guardrail caused the fall.
- No waiver. The carrier sues the general contractor for $120,000. The contractor's general liability carrier defends. Say it settles for $90,000 and spends $25,000 on defense: $115,000 lands on the contractor's policy and its loss history.
- Waiver on the sub's workers' comp policy. The carrier has no recovery right against the general contractor. The contractor's policy pays $0 on the subrogation claim.
- The reverse direction. The general contractor almost certainly promised the owner the same waiver in its own prime contract. If the contractor did not require it from the sub, the contractor is in breach of its own contract while its own insurer is exposed.
The waiver's value is the claim that never reaches the contractor's policy.
Why do contractors need waivers both up and down the chain?
Owners require waivers from general contractors, and general contractors pass the requirement down to subs. A contractor that gives a waiver upstream but does not collect one downstream is caught in the middle: its own insurer has waived rights against the owner, while the sub's insurer is free to come after the contractor.
Two practical points follow. First, your own policies must allow you to give the waivers your contracts promise; check the endorsement list with your broker. Second, the subcontract should require the same waivers your prime contract requires of you. The contract wording is your attorney's work; see contract insurance requirements for the checklist side.
Quick answers
What does waiver of subrogation mean in simple terms?
It means the insurer agrees not to sue a named party to get back money it paid on a claim. The claim still gets paid; the insurer just cannot recover it from that party.
Does a waiver of subrogation cost extra?
Often, yes. The NCCI-format workers' comp waiver endorsement includes a premium field, and carriers commonly charge a flat fee or a small percentage for specific or blanket waivers.
Is a waiver of subrogation the same as additional insured status?
No. Additional insured status brings you inside the sub's policy for claims against you; a waiver stops the sub's carrier from coming after you once it has paid. Construction contracts usually require both.
- Subrogation
- An insurer's right, after it pays a claim, to recover that money from whoever caused the loss.
- Waiver of subrogation
- An agreement, carried out by policy endorsement, that the insurer will not seek to recover a paid claim from a named party, such as the general contractor or owner.
- Certificate of insurance (COI)
- A one-page summary, usually on the ACORD 25 form, that shows a policyholder's insurers, policy numbers, dates and limits. It is evidence of coverage on the day it was issued, not a policy, and it grants the holder no rights.
- WC 00 03 13 Waiver of Our Right to Recover From Others Endorsement · North Carolina Rate Bureau (NCCI-format form)
- CG 24 04: Waiver of Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us · InsuranceXDate
- ACORD 25 Certificate of Liability Insurance (2016/03), blank form · National Park Service (hosting the ACORD form)
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.