Certificates of insurance (ACORD 25)

In short

A certificate of insurance (COI) is a one-page summary, usually on the ACORD 25 form, that a subcontractor's insurance agent issues to show what liability and workers' comp policies the sub carries. It is evidence that coverage existed on the day it was issued, not a policy: it grants the holder no rights, and additional insured status or a waiver of subrogation exists only if the endorsement itself is on the policy.

A general contractor cannot read every subcontractor's insurance policy before work starts. The certificate of insurance (COI) is the shortcut: a one-page summary, issued by the sub's insurance agent, that lists the sub's policies, dates and limits. The party that asks for it and receives it is the certificate holder. In the US, the standard form for liability coverage is the ACORD 25, Certificate of Liability Insurance, published by ACORD, an insurance-industry forms and data standards body.

Certificates are useful because they are standardized and dated. They are dangerous because they look like proof. The right way to read one is as an index card: it tells you which policies exist, which dates to watch and which endorsements to ask for.

What does an ACORD 25 show?

Every ACORD 25 is laid out the same way, which is what makes it fast to check:

  • Producer and insured. The sub's agent, and the sub's legal name. Match it to the name on your subcontract and on the sub's invoices.
  • Insurers. Each carrier, listed by letter with its NAIC company number.
  • Coverages. For each line (general liability, auto, umbrella, workers' comp): policy number, effective and expiration dates, and limits. The workers' comp section shows whether any owner, partner or officer is excluded from coverage.
  • ADDL INSD and SUBR WVD columns. Check boxes that say whether the holder is an additional insured and whether subrogation is waived on that line.
  • Description of operations. Free-text space for the project name and wording about additional insured status, waivers and primary wording.
  • Certificate holder and cancellation. Your company's name, and a sentence about notice if a policy is canceled.

What does a certificate of insurance not prove?

The current ACORD 25 edition (2016/03) says this on its face. The box at the top states that the certificate is issued for information only, gives the holder no rights, does not amend, extend or alter the coverage in the policies, and is not a contract between the insurers and the holder. It adds that if the holder is an additional insured, the policy must carry the endorsement, and that a waiver of subrogation may also need an endorsement; a statement on the certificate does not take the place of either.

In practice that means five gaps:

  1. Endorsements. A checked ADDL INSD box is the agent's statement, not the carrier's promise. Ask for the endorsement pages.
  2. Tomorrow. A policy can be canceled for non-payment the week after the certificate was issued. The cancellation wording says notice will be given under the policy's own provisions, which may give the holder little or no notice.
  3. Exclusions. A general liability policy that excludes residential work, or work by the sub's own subs, can still produce a clean-looking certificate.
  4. Excluded owners. A one-person sub whose workers' comp excludes the owner may have no one covered at all.
  5. Lower tiers. The certificate says nothing about the sub's own subcontractors.

Why does a missing certificate cost money at audit?

At the workers' comp premium audit, the carrier's auditor reviews what you paid to subcontractors. Payments to any sub who cannot show workers' comp in force for the days worked are typically treated as your own payroll and charged at your class rate, times your experience mod. If the invoices separate labor from materials, the auditor may remove the materials share; how much, and on what proof, depends on state rules and the carrier's audit practice. General liability audits charge for uninsured sub work as well.

A worked example (illustrative numbers)

A contractor pays $200,000 a year to subs who cannot produce a valid certificate. Its workers' comp class rate is $8.00 per $100 of payroll and its mod is 1.15.

  • Lump-sum invoices, no certificate: $200,000 / 100 x $8.00 x 1.15 = $18,400 of additional premium.
  • Invoices showing half the cost as materials, and the auditor accepts it: $100,000 / 100 x $8.00 x 1.15 = $9,200.
  • A certificate on file, but expired for 3 of the 12 months: about $50,000 uncovered, so about $4,600.
  • A valid certificate for every day worked: $0.

The fix costs nothing but discipline. That is why certificate compliance is one of the first numbers a Frost program measures.

How should a contractor check a certificate?

  1. Confirm the insured's name matches the subcontract and the invoices.
  2. Confirm general liability and workers' comp dates cover every day the sub will be on site, and put the expiration dates on a calendar.
  3. Compare limits to the minimums in your subcontract.
  4. Collect the additional insured, primary and noncontributory, and waiver endorsements, not just the checked boxes.
  5. Look for excluded officers on the workers' comp line.
  6. Re-check when a job runs past a sub's renewal date, and hold payment until a current certificate arrives.

Measure compliance by dollars of sub spend, not by number of subs. One uncovered framer can be half your spend. For the step-by-step office routine, see the guide on checking certificates of insurance. For what your subcontract should require in the first place, see contract insurance requirements.

Quick answers

Is a certificate of insurance proof of coverage?

It is evidence that coverage existed on the day it was issued, nothing more. The ACORD 25 itself says it confers no rights on the holder and does not change the policy, so it cannot prove coverage is still in force or that any endorsement exists.

Does being listed as certificate holder make me an additional insured?

No. Certificate holder status only means the certificate was sent to you. Additional insured status exists only if the sub's policy carries an additional insured endorsement that covers you.

How often should I collect new certificates from subcontractors?

At least at every policy renewal, and before any job that runs past a sub's expiration date. The test that matters at audit is coverage in force for every day the sub worked.

Terms in this entry
Certificate of insurance (COI)
A one-page summary, usually on the ACORD 25 form, that shows a policyholder's insurers, policy numbers, dates and limits. It is evidence of coverage on the day it was issued, not a policy, and it grants the holder no rights.
Certificate holder
The party a certificate of insurance is issued to, usually the general contractor or owner that asked for it. Being the holder does not by itself make that party an insured.
Additional insured
A party added by endorsement to someone else's liability policy, so that policy defends and pays for it on claims connected to the policyholder's work.
Waiver of subrogation
An agreement, carried out by policy endorsement, that the insurer will not seek to recover a paid claim from a named party, such as the general contractor or owner.
Experience mod (EMR)
A multiplier on workers' comp premium comparing your actual losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for your size and class mix. 1.00 is average; above it is a debit, below it a credit.
Sources and standards
  1. ACORD 25 Certificate of Liability Insurance (2016/03), blank form · National Park Service (hosting the ACORD form)
  2. 2013 ISO Additional Insured Endorsements: Putting the Changes into Context for the Construction Industry · IRMI
  3. WC 00 03 13 Waiver of Our Right to Recover From Others Endorsement · North Carolina Rate Bureau (NCCI-format form)

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
Contracts and subcontractorsAdditional insured endorsementsAn additional insured endorsement adds another party, such as a general contractor or owner, to a subcontractor's general liability policy for claims arising from the sub's work.Contracts and subcontractorsWaiver of subrogation explainedSubrogation is an insurer's right, after paying a claim, to recover that money from whoever caused the loss.Contracts and subcontractorsSubcontractor prequalificationSubcontractor prequalification is the process a general contractor uses to confirm, before a sub is hired, that it is licensed, insured, safe and financially able to do the work.Workers' comp and the experience modThe workers' comp premium auditA workers' comp policy is priced on estimated payroll and settled after it ends by a premium audit of actual payroll by class code.Contracts and subcontractorsPrimary and noncontributory insurancePrimary and noncontributory wording makes a subcontractor's liability policy pay first for the general contractor as additional insured (primary) and bars it from asking the contractor's own policy to share the loss (noncontributory).Resources · 5 min guideSubcontractor certificates of insurance and what they don't proveA certificate looks like proof, but it's only a snapshot. Here's what it shows, what it doesn't and a simple system so lapsed sub coverage never lands on your audit.Resources · 5 min guideInsurance requirements in construction contracts, explained in plain EnglishThe insurance section of a contract makes promises about your policies. Here's what each common term means, and why someone needs to check that your coverage matches before you sign.Resources · topicSubcontractors, contracts and certificates of insuranceSubs, certificates and the contracts you sign can quietly cost you money long after a job closes. Learn what the paperwork really proves and how to give it one owner.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent