The experience mod compares a contractor's actual workers' comp losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for its size and class mix. The formula counts the first dollars of every claim in full and the rest at a discount, so many small claims raise the mod more than one large one. A mod of 1.00 is average; 1.15 means 15% more premium.
What is the experience mod?
The experience modification factor, usually called the experience mod or mod, is a multiplier on workers' comp manual premium. It answers one question: over a recent three-year window, did this employer's injury losses run higher or lower than expected for an employer of its size doing the same kinds of work?
A mod of 1.00 means losses ran as expected. A mod of 1.15 is a 15% debit, so 15% more premium. A mod of 0.85 is a 15% credit. In Arizona and most other states, the plan and the calculation belong to NCCI, and the result is printed on the experience rating worksheet. Experience rating is mandatory for employers that meet their state's premium eligibility threshold.
What goes into the formula?
Five ideas build it.
- Expected losses. For each class code and year, payroll ÷ 100 × an expected loss rate set by NCCI. Summed, this is what an average employer with your payroll and class mix would have lost.
- Actual losses. Your own claims from the same years, valued at incurred (paid so far plus the carrier's reserve for what is still to be paid) as of the date the carrier reports them.
- The split point. Each claim is divided at a dollar threshold. The part up to it is primary loss; the part above it is excess loss. Expected losses are split the same way, using a D-ratio (the share of expected losses NCCI expects to be primary).
- Weighting (W). Primary losses count in full. Excess losses count only partly, multiplied by a weighting value between 0 and 1 that rises with employer size.
- Ballast (B). A fixed amount added to both sides of the ratio so that one claim cannot swing a small employer's mod wildly.
How is the experience mod calculated?
NCCI's published formula, in plain terms:
Mod = (actual primary + W × actual excess + (1 − W) × expected excess + B) ÷ (expected losses + B)
The bottom of the ratio is fixed once payroll and classes are known. The only parts an employer moves are the two actual-loss terms on top, and a dollar of primary loss moves the mod more than a dollar of excess loss.
A worked example
These numbers are illustrative, chosen to make the arithmetic visible. They are not NCCI's values; your real split point, W, B and expected losses are on your worksheet.
Assume expected losses of $100,000, of which $30,000 is expected primary and $70,000 expected excess; a $20,000 split point; W = 0.20; B = $50,000.
- Denominator: 100,000 + 50,000 = $150,000
- Fixed part of the top: (1 − 0.20) × 70,000 + 50,000 = $106,000
Now compare two employers with the same $100,000 of actual losses.
- Five claims of $20,000 each. All of it is primary. Top: 100,000 + 0 + 106,000 = 206,000. Mod: 206,000 ÷ 150,000 = 1.373.
- One claim of $100,000. Primary is $20,000 and excess is $80,000, counted at 0.20, so $16,000. Top: 20,000 + 16,000 + 106,000 = 142,000. Mod: 142,000 ÷ 150,000 = 0.947.
Same dollars, very different mods. The design is deliberate: NCCI explains that frequency predicts future losses better than severity, because an employer with many small injuries will likely keep having them, while one large claim is often bad luck. In this illustration each $1,000 of primary loss adds about 0.0067 to the mod, and each $1,000 of excess loss about 0.0013.
How do medical-only claims count?
A medical-only claim pays medical bills with no wage replacement. A lost-time claim includes indemnity. Under NCCI's Experience Rating Adjustment (ERA), approved in most states, only 30% of a medical-only claim's primary and excess amounts enter the mod, a 70% reduction. NCCI notes the rule reduces the incentive for employers to pay small claims quietly instead of reporting them.
Arizona applies it by statute: A.R.S. § 23-963.01(E) says the national rating organization's experience rating adjustment shall be applied to medical-only losses, including on deductible policies, and defines a medical-only loss as one with no indemnity value for lost wages.
Back to the example: if the five $20,000 claims had stayed medical-only, primary would be 5 × 20,000 × 0.30 = $30,000. Top: 30,000 + 106,000 = 136,000. Mod: 0.907 instead of 1.373. That gap is why return to work matters so much.
What about the split point?
The split point is not a constant. Before NCCI's methodology update, it was a single countrywide value, $18,500, updated with each state's annual loss cost or rate filing. With state filings effective from Nov 1, 2023 through Aug 1, 2024, NCCI moved to split points set state by state with each state's annual loss cost filing, so higher-severity states get higher split points. Since Oct 30, 2024, the worksheet's summary page shows the split point that applies to your rating. Read it there rather than remembering one.
Which numbers can an employer change?
- Expected loss rates, D-ratios, the split point, W and B: set by NCCI. Nobody negotiates them.
- Payroll and class: yours, through accurate reporting. See class codes and payroll.
- Actual primary and excess losses: yours, through how many claims happen, whether they stay medical-only, and how they are reported, reserved and closed.
That last list is the whole agenda, and the timing of it is covered in what moves the experience mod. It is also the number a Frost workers' comp plan is built around.
Quick answers
What is a good experience mod for a contractor?
Anything below 1.00 means losses ran better than expected for your size and class mix. Some general contractors and project owners also screen subcontractors on the mod, so a debit mod can cost work as well as premium.
Why did one big claim not raise my mod as much as several small ones?
Only the part of each claim up to the split point counts in full. A large claim is mostly excess loss, which the formula discounts, while several small claims are almost entirely primary loss.
Do medical-only claims count toward my experience mod?
Yes, but at a reduced value in most NCCI states, including Arizona. Under the Experience Rating Adjustment only 30% of a medical-only claim enters the calculation.
- Experience mod (EMR)
- A multiplier on workers' comp premium comparing your actual losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for your size and class mix. 1.00 is average; above it is a debit, below it a credit.
- Split point
- The dollar line that divides each claim into primary loss (counted in full in the mod) and excess loss (discounted). NCCI sets it by state, and it is printed on the experience rating worksheet.
- Primary and excess losses
- The part of a claim up to the split point (primary) and the part above it (excess). Primary losses drive the experience mod much more than excess losses.
- Experience Rating Adjustment (ERA)
- NCCI's rule that counts only 30% of a medical-only claim in the experience mod, a 70% reduction. Arizona applies it by statute.
- ABCs of Experience Rating · NCCI
- Experience Rating Plan Methodology Update FAQs · NCCI
- Introducing NCCI's Updated Experience Rating Worksheet Format · NCCI
- A.R.S. § 23-963.01, Deductible coverage; medical-only losses · Arizona State Legislature
- Workers' Compensation Rates Decrease for 10th Consecutive Year · Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.