An indemnity (hold-harmless) clause is a contract promise by one party to pay for and defend another against certain losses. In Arizona, A.R.S. 32-1159 voids private construction contract clauses that make one party cover another's sole negligence, and A.R.S. 34-226 and 41-2586 limit public-project indemnity further, so the form a contract uses is a question for a construction attorney. Arizona is the worked example; the rule in your state may differ.
An indemnity clause, also called a hold-harmless clause, is a promise in a contract by one party (the indemnitor) to pay for and defend another party (the indemnitee) against certain claims. In contracting, subcontracts usually require the sub to indemnify the general contractor and the owner for claims arising from the sub's work.
The clause says who should pay. It does not say who can. A promise from a small sub with a thin balance sheet is worth only what the sub can pay, which is why indemnity is always paired with insurance requirements: additional insured status, primary and noncontributory wording and a waiver of subrogation.
This entry explains the concepts and the Arizona statutes. It is not legal advice, and it deliberately contains no sample language. Indemnity clauses should be drafted and reviewed by a construction attorney.
What are the three forms of indemnity?
The industry sorts indemnity clauses by how much of the indemnitee's own fault they shift. The classification below follows IRMI's.
- Limited form. The sub pays only for losses caused by its own negligence. This is close to where the law would land anyway, and it protects the general contractor when it is sued only because it was in charge of the site.
- Intermediate form. The sub pays for losses caused by its own negligence and for losses where both parties were negligent, which can include the general contractor's share.
- Broad form. The sub pays even when the general contractor was solely at fault. IRMI notes that broad form agreements are unenforceable in a number of states.
What does Arizona law say about construction indemnity?
Arizona has three statutes that matter, and which one applies depends on who the owner is.
- A.R.S. 32-1159, private projects. A clause in a construction contract or an architect-engineer services contract that purports to indemnify a party against liability for losses caused by that party's sole negligence is void as against Arizona public policy. The statute applies to contracts between private parties. In short, broad form fails on private Arizona work; the statute's text does not reach limited or intermediate form.
- A.R.S. 34-226, public building and improvement projects of political subdivisions. Cities, counties and other political subdivisions may require contractors, subcontractors and design professionals to indemnify them only to the extent the loss was caused by the indemnitor's own negligence, recklessness or intentional wrongful conduct, or that of people it employs or uses. Requirements beyond that are void. The statute expressly allows insurance requirements, including additional insured status, and makes construction indemnity a matter of statewide concern that local governments cannot regulate further.
- A.R.S. 41-2586, state agency contracts. A clause in a state construction contract or subcontract that indemnifies the promisee against its own negligence is void, and design professional indemnity is limited to the extent caused by the design professional's fault. Insurance requirements, including additional insured status, are allowed.
Each statute has an accommodation exception: a contractor may fully indemnify a neighboring property owner who lets the contractor use or work next to its property as a favor.
A worked example: one loss, three clauses (illustrative numbers)
A passer-by is injured on a private Arizona project and recovers $500,000. A jury finds the general contractor 70% at fault and the sub 30% at fault.
- Limited form. The sub owes its own share: 30% x $500,000 = $150,000. The contractor carries $350,000.
- Intermediate form. Both parties were negligent, so the clause as written shifts the full $500,000 to the sub. 32-1159 voids only sole-negligence indemnity, so on its text the statute does not block this, but enforceability turns on the exact wording and Arizona case law.
- Broad form, different facts. Now the contractor is 100% at fault. The clause would shift the full $500,000 to the sub, but 32-1159 voids it. The sub owes $0 under the clause, and the contractor carries the loss.
On a city project under 34-226, the same 70/30 loss would be shared by fault: the sub's indemnity obligation to the city reaches only the 30% its own conduct caused.
Why do the insurance requirements matter more than the clause?
A void clause gives nothing, however strong it reads. A valid clause from an uninsured sub gives little. The insurance requirements are what make the sub's insurer, not the sub's bank account, stand behind the promise. The 2013 and later ISO additional insured endorsements say the coverage applies only as far as the law allows, so in Arizona the insurance and the statute point the same direction.
Contractors also give indemnity, upstream to owners. Your general liability policy's contractual liability coverage, which covers liability you assume under an "insured contract," is what responds to that promise. Ask your broker whether your policy covers the indemnity you are signing.
Where does the attorney come in?
Choosing the form your subcontracts require, reviewing what an owner asks you to give and deciding how a clause holds up under Arizona case law are decisions for your construction attorney. The insurance side, making sure the endorsements match the contract, is your broker's work. See contract insurance requirements for what to bring to both conversations.
Quick answers
Is broad form indemnity enforceable in Arizona?
Not on private construction contracts to the extent it covers the indemnitee's sole negligence; A.R.S. 32-1159 makes that void. Public contracts under A.R.S. 34-226 and 41-2586 are more restrictive still, so have your attorney review any clause before you sign.
What is the difference between indemnity and additional insured status?
Indemnity is the sub's contractual promise to pay; additional insured status puts you inside the sub's insurance policy. The promise depends on the sub's ability to pay, while the endorsement is backed by an insurer.
Can a contractor write its own indemnity clause?
It should not. Indemnity enforceability turns on statute, case law and precise wording, so the clause should be drafted or reviewed by a construction attorney licensed in the state where the work is done.
- Indemnity (hold-harmless) clause
- A contract promise by one party to pay for and defend another against certain losses. It comes in limited, intermediate and broad forms, depending on how much of the other party's own fault it shifts.
- Anti-indemnity statute
- A state law that voids some indemnity clauses in construction contracts. Arizona's A.R.S. 32-1159 voids clauses that make one party cover another's sole negligence on private work.
- Additional insured
- A party added by endorsement to someone else's liability policy, so that policy defends and pays for it on claims connected to the policyholder's work.
- A.R.S. 32-1159, Indemnity agreements in construction and architect-engineer contracts void · Arizona State Legislature
- A.R.S. 34-226, Indemnity agreements in public construction and design professional contracts · Arizona State Legislature
- A.R.S. 41-2586, Indemnity agreements in state construction and design professional contracts · Arizona State Legislature
- Hold harmless agreement (definition) · IRMI
- 2013 ISO Additional Insured Endorsements: Putting the Changes into Context for the Construction Industry · IRMI
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.