Primary and noncontributory wording makes a subcontractor's liability policy pay first for the general contractor as additional insured (primary) and bars it from asking the contractor's own policy to share the loss (noncontributory). It is usually created by endorsement, such as ISO CG 20 01, and it only works where additional insured status already exists.
When a sub's work causes an injury and the general contractor is sued, two policies may cover the same claim: the sub's general liability policy, under which the contractor is an additional insured, and the contractor's own general liability policy. Something has to decide which one pays and in what order.
Primary and noncontributory wording settles it in the general contractor's favor. Primary means the sub's policy pays first, before any other policy available to the contractor. Noncontributory means the sub's policy will not ask the contractor's own policy to share the loss.
How do other insurance clauses work?
Every general liability policy has an other insurance condition that says what happens when more than one policy covers the same loss. In the standard ISO form, a policy is usually primary, and when two primary policies apply they share the loss, either in equal shares or in proportion to their limits, depending on what both policies allow.
Sharing sounds fair, but for a general contractor it means a claim caused by a sub's crew partly lands on the contractor's own policy, in the contractor's loss runs, and possibly within the contractor's deductible. The subcontract said the sub's insurance would handle it; the other insurance clauses quietly split it.
How is primary and noncontributory coverage created?
Most often by endorsement. ISO's standard form is CG 20 01, Primary and Noncontributory, Other Insurance Condition; the current edition is 12 19, which replaced the 04 13 edition. In plain terms, it makes the sub's coverage for an additional insured primary and noncontributory when two things are true:
- The additional insured is a named insured on its own other insurance, which is the case for a general contractor with its own policy.
- The sub agreed in a written contract that its insurance would be primary and would not seek contribution from the additional insured's insurance.
Some carriers build the same effect into their own blanket additional insured endorsements. Either way, the coverage turns on the written contract, so a missing or unsigned subcontract can undo it.
A worked example (illustrative numbers)
A sub's crew leaves a trench unprotected and a delivery driver is injured. The claim settles for $900,000 against the general contractor. The sub's policy names the contractor as additional insured, and both the sub and the contractor carry $1,000,000 per occurrence.
- No primary and noncontributory wording, equal shares. Each policy pays half: $450,000 from the sub's policy and $450,000 from the contractor's. The contractor's policy now shows a $450,000 paid claim, and if the contractor carries a $25,000 deductible, that comes out of its pocket too.
- Primary and noncontributory wording in place. The sub's policy pays the full $900,000. The contractor's policy pays $0 and its loss runs show no paid loss for this claim.
The contractor in case 2 has protected not just this claim but its next renewal: underwriters price from loss history, and a $450,000 paid liability loss is hard to explain away.
What doesn't primary and noncontributory do?
- It does not add limits. If the claim exceeds the sub's policy limit, the excess still goes somewhere, often to the contractor's policy or umbrella.
- It does not work without additional insured status. It describes how the sub's policy treats the contractor as an insured; if the contractor is not an insured, there is nothing to make primary.
- It does not reach the sub's umbrella automatically. Many subcontracts also require the sub's umbrella or excess policy to respond before the contractor's own umbrella. Whether the sub's umbrella follows the underlying wording depends on that policy's terms, so ask for confirmation.
- It is not proven by a certificate. A line in the description box of a certificate of insurance is not the endorsement. Ask for the endorsement page.
Where does it fit in the subcontract?
Primary and noncontributory sits alongside additional insured status, waivers of subrogation and the indemnity clause as one of the four requirements that push a sub's losses back onto the sub's insurer. Owners usually require the same wording from the general contractor, so the contractor needs it from every sub to avoid sitting in the middle.
What the subcontract requires, and the exact words, belong to your construction attorney. Collecting and checking the endorsements belongs to your office and your broker. See contract insurance requirements for the checklist.
Quick answers
What does primary and noncontributory mean?
Primary means the subcontractor's policy pays first for the additional insured. Noncontributory means that policy will not ask the additional insured's own policy to share the loss.
Which ISO endorsement provides primary and noncontributory coverage?
ISO form CG 20 01, Primary and Noncontributory, Other Insurance Condition. Some carriers achieve the same result through their own blanket additional insured endorsements.
Do I need primary and noncontributory if I am already an additional insured?
Usually, yes. Without it, the sub's policy and your own may share the loss under their other insurance clauses, putting part of the claim on your policy and loss history.
- Primary and noncontributory
- Policy wording that makes a sub's policy pay first for an additional insured and bars it from asking the additional insured's own policy to share the loss.
- Additional insured
- A party added by endorsement to someone else's liability policy, so that policy defends and pays for it on claims connected to the policyholder's work.
- CG 20 01 04 13 Primary and Noncontributory - Other Insurance Condition · ISO form as filed by Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance
- 2013 ISO Additional Insured Endorsements: Putting the Changes into Context for the Construction Industry · IRMI
- ACORD 25 Certificate of Liability Insurance (2016/03), blank form · National Park Service (hosting the ACORD form)
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.