Retention vs transfer: choosing what to keep

In short

Retention means paying some losses yourself, through a deductible, SIR or budget; transfer means paying a carrier or another party to carry them. The right mix keeps frequent, predictable losses and transfers rare, severe ones, and compares options on expected annual cost and worst-case year, never on premium alone.

Every contractor finances its losses somehow. The question is how much to keep and how much to pay someone else to carry. Retention means paying losses yourself, on purpose, inside a deductible, a self-insured retention or a budget line. Transfer means paying a carrier, or another party by contract, to carry them. Most programs mix the two, and getting the mix right is one of the larger levers in a contractor's total cost of risk.

What is the risk financing ladder?

Each rung keeps more losses and pays less premium:

  1. Guaranteed cost. The carrier pays every claim; your cost is the premium, fixed for the year whatever happens. The default for most small and mid-size contractors.
  2. Dividend plan. Still guaranteed cost, but part of the premium may come back if losses are low. Dividends are not guaranteed.
  3. Small deductible. You repay the first few thousand dollars of each claim. The carrier still handles it.
  4. Large deductible. You repay each claim up to a large per-claim amount, often under an aggregate that caps the year. The carrier handles claims and requires collateral, usually a letter of credit.
  5. Self-insured retention or self-insurance. You pay and handle claims below the retention before any policy responds. Workers' comp self-insurance needs state approval; in Arizona, A.R.S. 23-961 requires Industrial Commission authorization and allows it to demand security of at least $100,000.
  6. Captive. An insurance company you, or a group of companies, own pays the claims, with reinsurance above it. The most control and the most work.

The mechanics of rungs 3 through 5 are covered in deductibles vs self-insured retentions.

Which losses should a contractor keep?

The classic guide is the frequency and severity of the losses. Losses that are frequent but small, such as minor strains and cuts, are predictable enough to budget, and retaining them pays you for preventing them. Losses that are rare but severe, such as a fall from height or a serious vehicle crash, are what insurance is for. Exposures that are both frequent and severe should be avoided or reduced before anyone talks about financing them.

In short: keep what is frequent and predictable, transfer what is rare and severe.

How do you compare a deductible with guaranteed cost?

Never on premium alone. For each option, add four things:

  • Premium.
  • Expected retained losses: your loss pick times the share of your loss dollars that falls inside the retention.
  • Collateral cost: the collateral amount times your bank's annual fee for it.
  • Claims handling: a third-party administrator or the carrier's per-claim fees.

Then compute the worst case: premium plus the aggregate cap plus collateral cost plus handling. If there is no aggregate, the worst case has no ceiling.

A worked example

Illustrative numbers for a workers' comp line. Loss pick: $100,000. The contractor's past claims were $50,000, $50,000 and $300,000.

Retained share at a $100,000 per-claim deductible: the portion of each claim inside the deductible is 50,000 + 50,000 + 100,000 = $200,000 of $400,000 total, or 50%.

Option 1, guaranteed cost: premium $180,000. Expected cost $180,000. Worst case $180,000.

Option 2, $100,000 large deductible: premium $110,000; aggregate $200,000; collateral $100,000 at a 1.5% annual fee; claims handling $5,000.

  • Expected retained losses: 100,000 × 50% = $50,000
  • Collateral cost: 100,000 × 0.015 = $1,500
  • Expected cost: 110,000 + 50,000 + 1,500 + 5,000 = $166,500
  • Difference from guaranteed cost: 166,500 − 180,000 = −$13,500
  • Worst case: 110,000 + 200,000 + 1,500 + 5,000 = $316,500

The premium falls by $70,000, but the expected saving is $13,500. In a year that hits the aggregate, the deductible costs 316,500 − 180,000 = $136,500 more than guaranteed cost. Break-even: the deductible wins as long as retained losses stay under 50,000 + 13,500 = $63,500.

What makes retention a good idea?

Moving up the ladder makes sense when:

  • Losses are frequent enough to be predictable, and several years of developed history support the loss pick.
  • The balance sheet can absorb the worst case without strain.
  • Controls are running: injuries reported within days, claims managed closely, a return-to-work program in place.
  • Borrowing capacity can spare the letter of credit. Collateral costs a fee every year and uses up credit the business may need for payroll in a slow month.

It is a poor idea when losses are thin or erratic, when one large claim would hurt the business, or when the premium saving is being shown without the retained losses that bought it.

Who decides?

The arithmetic narrows the choice; the owner's risk appetite makes it. A useful question is simply: which bad year could you write a check for? If the answer is "not $136,500," the deductible in the example is outside appetite, however good its expected cost looks. Recording that limit is part of a risk register and risk appetite. This comparison is the one an approved agent runs in Frost, and the owner's guide to deductibles and retention covers how to raise it with your carrier. Tax and accounting treatment of retained losses and collateral is a question for your CPA.

Quick answers

What is the difference between risk retention and risk transfer?

Retention means paying losses yourself, through a deductible, SIR or budget. Transfer means paying an insurer or another party to carry them, usually through premium or contract terms.

When should a contractor take a higher deductible?

When losses are frequent and predictable, the business can absorb the worst-case year, collateral fits within its credit, and the expected cost (premium plus retained losses, collateral and handling) is lower than guaranteed cost.

Is a lower premium always a saving?

No. A lower premium from a larger deductible is only a saving if it exceeds the retained losses, collateral cost and handling fees it brings with it.

Terms in this entry
Retention
Losses a business pays itself, on purpose, through a deductible, a self-insured retention or a budget, usually in exchange for a lower premium.
Guaranteed cost
A policy with no meaningful retention: the carrier pays the claims and the policyholder's cost is the premium.
Large-deductible program
A workers' comp or liability policy with a per-claim deductible in the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars, usually requiring collateral.
Aggregate stop
A cap on the total retained losses a policyholder can owe in a policy year under a deductible or retention program.
Collateral (letter of credit)
Security, most often a bank letter of credit, that a carrier holds against deductible amounts it has paid or expects to pay but has not yet collected.
Loss pick
An estimate of one future year's expected losses, built from developed past losses and exposure. Also called expected losses.
Sources and standards
  1. Risk Management Alternatives: The Risk Management Matrix · Saylor Academy (Risk Management for Enterprises and Individuals)
  2. Large deductible programs: Demystifying collateral · Milliman
  3. Loss pick · IRMI
  4. A.R.S. 23-961, Securing compensation; self-insurance · Arizona State Legislature
  5. Self-Insured Retentions versus Deductibles · IRMI

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent