Admitted vs. surplus lines insurance

In short

An admitted insurer is licensed by the state, files its forms and rates, and is backed by the state guaranty fund. A surplus lines (E&S) insurer is not licensed in the state, writes risks the admitted market will not, has no guaranty fund backing, and in Arizona its premium carries a 3% tax plus a stamping fee. Arizona is the worked example; the rule in your state may differ.

Where a policy is placed changes both what a contractor pays and what protection sits behind the promise. Every commercial policy is placed in one of two markets: admitted or surplus lines.

What is an admitted insurer?

An admitted insurer holds a license, called a certificate of authority, from the state insurance regulator. In Arizona that is the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions. Admitted carriers file their policy forms and rates with the state, and their policyholders are protected by the state guaranty fund if the carrier becomes insolvent.

Arizona's property and casualty guaranty fund is funded by licensed insurers and pays covered claims of an insolvent licensed insurer. Under A.R.S. § 20-667, it pays the part of each covered claim above $100 and below $300,000 (workers' comp claims follow their own rules), and never more than the policy limit. Surplus lines insurers are not members of the fund (A.R.S. § 20-661).

What is surplus lines (E&S) insurance?

A surplus lines insurer, also called E&S (excess and surplus) or nonadmitted, is not licensed in the state but is allowed to write certain risks there through a licensed surplus lines broker. It sets its own forms and rates. E&S carriers write what the admitted market declines or will not price: unusual operations, heavy loss history, new ventures, some residential and roofing work, and high-hazard classes.

Arizona controls when a placement can go to the E&S market:

  • It must go through a surplus lines broker licensed in Arizona (A.R.S. § 20-407, § 20-411).
  • The coverage must be either a recognized surplus line the Director has declared not readily available (A.R.S. § 20-409), or unavailable after a diligent effort, defined as seeking coverage from at least three insurers authorized in Arizona (A.R.S. § 20-401).
  • The policy must carry a bold notice that the insurer has no certificate of authority and that guaranty fund protection does not apply (A.R.S. § 20-410).

None of this makes E&S "bad insurance." For some risks it is the only market, and a sound E&S form is far better than no coverage. The questions are the form and the total cost.

What does surplus lines cost on top of premium in Arizona?

Two charges ride on an E&S premium.

  • Surplus lines tax. A.R.S. § 20-416 sets it at 3% of gross premium, including policy fees but excluding stamping fees. The broker collects it from the insured on top of the premium, may not absorb or rebate it, and refunds the tax on any unearned premium when a policy is canceled. If a surplus lines broker charges a service fee, A.R.S. § 20-410 requires written disclosure and agreement beforehand, and the 3% tax applies to that fee too.
  • Stamping fee. Arizona lets the Director contract with an association of surplus lines brokers to process filings and charge a stamping fee (A.R.S. § 20-167, § 20-408). As of 2026, the published rate is 0.20% of premium. Confirm the current rate on the invoice or with the surplus lines broker.

An admitted policy carries neither charge.

A worked example: the same GL both ways

A contractor's general liability is placed E&S at $95,000. The tax and stamping arithmetic is real; the admitted quotes are illustrative.

  1. Surplus lines tax: 95,000 × 3% = $2,850
  2. Stamping fee: 95,000 × 0.20% = $190
  3. E&S cost of the line: 95,000 + 2,850 + 190 = $98,040
  4. If the line moves to an admitted carrier at the same $95,000, the contractor saves $3,040 a year and gains guaranty fund protection

Real admitted quotes are rarely the same number, so compare the totals:

  • Admitted at $97,000: cheaper than E&S by 98,040 − 97,000 = $1,040
  • Admitted at $99,000: more expensive by 99,000 − 98,040 = $960

In the second case, E&S wins on price. Whether it is the right answer depends on the two policy forms: exclusions, the deductible, how additional insured status is granted, and whether defense costs reduce the limit. The tax is the fixed, known part of the comparison; the premium and form need a quote and a careful read.

When does it make sense to move from E&S to admitted?

When the admitted market will write the risk on a form at least as broad, at a total cost that is lower once the tax and fees are counted. Contractors often land in E&S after a bad year or simply because a prior broker put them there and never remarketed. Improving loss history and documenting safety controls can bring an account back into the admitted market's appetite. That work happens on the renewal timeline, well before quotes arrive.

Three practical checks:

  • Read the dec page for the market. An E&S policy carries the guaranty fund notice.
  • Read the invoice. The tax line should be 3% of premium plus taxable fees, and the stamping fee should be separate.
  • Ask why. If the general liability is E&S, ask what kept it out of the admitted market and whether that reason still applies.

Policies covering exposures in several states can be taxed by the insured's home state at that state's rate (A.R.S. § 20-401, § 20-416). This entry describes Arizona law; it is not legal or tax advice, and placement decisions should involve your broker and, where needed, your attorney or CPA. For how these charges show up next to commission and broker fees, see broker compensation, fees and taxes.

Quick answers

What is the surplus lines tax in Arizona?

3% of gross premium, including policy fees but not stamping fees, under A.R.S. § 20-416. The surplus lines broker collects it from the insured on top of the premium and may not absorb or rebate it.

Is surplus lines insurance covered by the Arizona guaranty fund?

No. Arizona's property and casualty guaranty fund covers licensed (admitted) insurers, and every surplus lines policy must carry a notice saying guaranty fund protection does not apply (A.R.S. § 20-410).

Why is my contractor's general liability with a surplus lines carrier?

Usually because admitted carriers declined the risk or would not price it, often due to the type of work or loss history. Arizona requires a diligent effort with at least three admitted insurers first, unless the coverage is a recognized surplus line.

Terms in this entry
Admitted insurer
An insurer licensed by the state, with policy forms and rates filed with the regulator, whose policyholders are protected by the state guaranty fund if it fails.
Surplus lines (E&S) insurance
Coverage from an insurer not licensed in the state, placed through a licensed surplus lines broker for risks the admitted market will not write. It has no guaranty fund backing and carries a state tax.
Surplus lines tax
A state tax on surplus lines premium, collected from the insured by the broker. In Arizona it is 3% of gross premium including policy fees, excluding stamping fees (A.R.S. § 20-416).
Stamping fee
A filing fee charged on surplus lines policies by the association that processes them for the state. In Arizona it is billed separately and is not subject to the surplus lines tax.
Sources and standards
  1. A.R.S. § 20-416, Tax on surplus lines · Arizona State Legislature
  2. A.R.S. § 20-410, Validity of surplus lines insurance; disclosure; policy fees · Arizona State Legislature
  3. A.R.S. § 20-401, Definitions (diligent effort, home state) · Arizona State Legislature
  4. A.R.S. § 20-667, Obligations of the fund · Arizona State Legislature
  5. A.R.S. § 20-167, Fees (stamping fee) · Arizona State Legislature
  6. Surplus Lines Law Manual: Arizona (stamping fee 0.20%) · Troutman Pepper Locke LLP

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
The insurance programBroker compensation, fees and taxesWhat a contractor pays for insurance is more than the premiums.The insurance programCommercial general liability (CGL) insuranceCommercial general liability (CGL) insurance pays when a business is legally responsible for injury to other people or damage to their property, from its premises, its operations, or work it has completed.The insurance programThe insurance renewal timelineA commercial insurance renewal is a process that starts about 120 days before the policy expires, not a quote that arrives a few weeks out.Contracts and subcontractorsAdditional insured endorsementsAn additional insured endorsement adds another party, such as a general contractor or owner, to a subcontractor's general liability policy for claims arising from the sub's work.The insurance programHow insurance premium is builtA commercial insurance premium is a chain of steps: exposure times rate gives the manual premium, which is then adjusted by the experience mod, schedule credits or debits, and a premium discount, before flat charges, fees and taxes are added.Resources · 5 min guideHow to prepare an insurance renewal submission underwriters can creditUnderwriters don't price your company. They price your file. Here's what goes in it, and why the real work starts 120 days out.Resources · 5 min guideSigns your contracting company needs a year-round risk programThere's an awkward middle every growing contracting company hits. Here's how to tell if you're in it, and how to get out without hiring a risk department.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent