Umbrella and excess liability insurance

In short

Umbrella and excess liability policies add limits above a contractor's general liability, auto and employers liability policies. An umbrella can also drop down when an underlying aggregate is used up and may cover some claims the underlying policies do not, while a true excess policy only adds limits and is no broader than what sits beneath it.

Primary liability policies have limits, and serious contractor claims can exceed them. A fall from height, a crash involving a loaded truck, or a structural failure can produce a verdict well over $1,000,000. Umbrella and excess liability policies are how a contractor buys limits above that line.

The two names are often used as if they mean the same thing. They do not, and the difference matters when a claim does not fit neatly.

What does an umbrella policy do?

An umbrella liability policy sits over several primary policies at once, typically commercial general liability, commercial auto, and employers liability (Part Two of the workers' comp policy). It does three jobs:

  1. Adds limits. When a covered claim exhausts an underlying limit, the umbrella pays the rest, up to its own limit.
  2. Drops down. When an underlying aggregate limit has been used up by earlier claims, the umbrella steps into the primary position for later claims.
  3. Fills some gaps. An umbrella may cover certain claims the underlying policies exclude. For those, the insured first pays a self-insured retention, a set amount the business pays itself before the umbrella responds.

How broad an umbrella is depends on its form, which is not standardized. Many contractor umbrellas today are close to follow form, so the third job may be narrow or missing.

How is excess liability different?

An excess liability policy only adds limits. It is no broader than the policy under it. A follow form excess policy adopts the terms of the underlying policy for most provisions, with some exclusions and conditions of its own. If the underlying policy does not cover a claim, the excess will not either.

Larger contractors often buy a tower: a lead umbrella over the primary policies, then one or more excess layers stacked above it, each from a different carrier if needed.

A worked example: who pays what

Illustrative program: GL $1,000,000 each occurrence and $2,000,000 aggregate; auto $1,000,000 combined single limit; umbrella $5,000,000; excess $5,000,000 above the umbrella.

  • A $3,000,000 GL claim. GL pays $1,000,000. The umbrella pays 3,000,000 − 1,000,000 = $2,000,000. The excess layer is untouched.
  • A $7,500,000 auto claim. Auto pays $1,000,000. The umbrella pays its full $5,000,000. The excess pays 7,500,000 − 1,000,000 − 5,000,000 = $1,500,000.
  • An aggregate used up. Earlier claims have used the full $2,000,000 GL general aggregate. A new $400,000 operations claim arrives. The GL pays nothing. The umbrella drops down and pays the $400,000, subject to its own terms.
  • A claim the GL excludes. If the umbrella covers it, the contractor first pays the retention, say an illustrative $10,000, and the umbrella pays the next $390,000. If the umbrella follows the GL exclusion, the contractor pays the full $400,000.

The same $400,000 claim can cost the contractor $0, $10,000, or $400,000, depending on the forms.

What does an umbrella require underneath it?

Every umbrella and excess policy has a schedule of underlying insurance and a condition that the insured keep those policies in force at the stated limits. If an underlying policy lapses, is reduced, or is replaced with a narrower one, the umbrella may treat the insured as if the missing coverage were still there. The contractor then pays the gap itself. Changing a primary carrier or limit at renewal means checking the umbrella's schedule at the same time.

What do construction contracts ask of umbrellas?

Owners and general contractors usually set limits as a combination: for example, $1,000,000 primary GL plus a $5,000,000 umbrella. Common requirements include:

  • The umbrella must follow form over the primary policies.
  • Additional insured status must extend to the umbrella, not only the GL.
  • Coverage must be primary and noncontributory to the owner's own insurance, at the umbrella level too.
  • Completed operations coverage must continue for years after the job ends.

Each of those is a policy wording question, so the umbrella form needs to be read against the contract. The contract insurance requirements guide covers how to check them before signing.

How is an umbrella priced?

Umbrella premium is set mostly by the underlying exposures: payroll and revenue on the GL, number and type of vehicles on the auto, and the loss history across all of them. Fleets and high-hazard work drive the price up. Each higher excess layer usually costs less per $1,000,000 than the layer below it, because claims large enough to reach it are rarer. Choosing how much a contractor keeps itself versus buys is a deductible versus self-insured retention question as much as a limits question.

This entry describes common policy structures, not any specific form. Coverage depends on the exact wording, so have your broker compare the umbrella to each underlying policy, and talk to your attorney about contract requirements.

Quick answers

What is the difference between umbrella and excess liability insurance?

An umbrella sits over several primary policies, can drop down when an underlying aggregate is exhausted, and may cover some claims the underlying policies do not, subject to a retention. A true excess policy only adds limits and is no broader than the policy beneath it.

What does follow form mean?

A follow form excess policy adopts the terms of the underlying policy for most provisions, so it covers what the underlying covers and excludes what it excludes, with a few conditions of its own.

Does an umbrella cover workers' comp?

It does not pay workers' comp benefits, which have no dollar limit under state law. It usually sits over employers liability, Part Two of the workers' comp policy, which covers lawsuits arising from employee injuries.

Terms in this entry
Follow form
An excess or umbrella policy that adopts the terms of the policy beneath it for most provisions, so it generally covers what the underlying covers and excludes what it excludes.
Self-insured retention (SIR)
An amount the insured pays and handles itself before the policy responds at all. Coverage applies only above the retention.
Sources and standards
  1. Umbrella liability policy (definition) · IRMI
  2. Excess liability policy (definition) · IRMI
  3. Follow form (definition) · IRMI
  4. Self-insured retention (definition) · IRMI

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
The insurance programCommercial general liability (CGL) insuranceCommercial general liability (CGL) insurance pays when a business is legally responsible for injury to other people or damage to their property, from its premises, its operations, or work it has completed.The insurance programContractor insurance lines explainedA contractor's insurance program is a set of separate policies, called lines, and each one pays for a defined kind of loss and is priced on its own measure of exposure.Contracts and subcontractorsAdditional insured endorsementsAn additional insured endorsement adds another party, such as a general contractor or owner, to a subcontractor's general liability policy for claims arising from the sub's work.Retention and loss financingDeductibles vs self-insured retentionsUnder a deductible, the insurance carrier handles and pays the whole claim, then bills you back for your share.Contracts and subcontractorsPrimary and noncontributory insurancePrimary and noncontributory wording makes a subcontractor's liability policy pay first for the general contractor as additional insured (primary) and bars it from asking the contractor's own policy to share the loss (noncontributory).Resources · 5 min guideInsurance requirements in construction contracts, explained in plain EnglishThe insurance section of a contract makes promises about your policies. Here's what each common term means, and why someone needs to check that your coverage matches before you sign.Resources · 5 min guideCommercial auto insurance and fleet safety for contractorsOne crash can land on two policies. Here are the four fleet controls that change what a carrier sees when it looks at your trucks.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent