What a contractor pays for insurance is more than the premiums. Broker commission is already inside the premium, while broker fees, policy fees, surplus lines tax and stamping fees are billed on top; contingent commission is paid by carriers after the fact and never appears on an invoice.
The cost of an insurance program is the premiums plus everything that rides on them. Some of those charges show up on the invoice. Some are inside the premium and never show up at all. Knowing which is which keeps a contractor from undercounting the real price, or counting the same dollar twice.
How are insurance brokers paid?
There are two main ways, and a broker may use either or both.
- Commission is a percentage of the premium that the insurance company pays the broker. It is built into the premium. The contractor never writes a separate check for it, and often never sees the amount.
- A broker fee is billed directly to the contractor, on top of the premium, in place of or in addition to commission.
A third form never touches the contractor's invoice. Contingent commission is a bonus an insurer pays a broker based on the profitability or volume of all the business that broker placed with it. It rewards brokers for steering good business to that carrier. It is legal, but because it can pull against the client's interest, it should be disclosed.
What other fees and taxes appear on a premium invoice?
- Policy fee: a flat charge from the insurer or a wholesale broker for issuing the policy
- Surplus lines tax: charged only when a policy is placed with a nonadmitted carrier; see admitted vs. surplus lines insurance
- Stamping fee: charged by the surplus lines association that processes the filing
- Inspection or audit fees, where a carrier bills them separately
What does Arizona law say about fees?
Arizona's general producer fee rule, A.R.S. § 20-465, requires written disclosure and agreement before a producer charges a fee on top of premium. But § 20-465(E) says that section does not apply to producers transacting commercial insurance, which covers most of a contractor's program. Fee arrangements on commercial accounts are a matter of agreement between the contractor and the broker, which is all the more reason to get them in writing.
Surplus lines placements have their own rules:
- A surplus lines broker may charge a service fee only if the fee and the services it pays for are disclosed and agreed to in writing before coverage is placed (A.R.S. § 20-410).
- The 3% surplus lines tax applies to the premium and to policy fees, including that service fee, but not to the stamping fee (A.R.S. § 20-410, § 20-416).
- The broker must collect the tax from the insured and may not absorb it or rebate any part of the tax or commission (A.R.S. § 20-416).
This summarizes the statutes; it is not legal advice. Talk to your attorney or CPA about any specific fee agreement or tax treatment.
A worked example: reading a premium summary
Illustrative contractor program, from the invoices:
- Premiums for five lines: 180,000 + 95,000 + 48,000 + 12,000 + 22,000 = $357,000
- Surplus lines tax on the $95,000 general liability placed E&S: 95,000 × 3% = $2,850
- Fees billed separately (broker, policy and stamping fees): $500
- Total cost of the program: 357,000 + 2,850 + 500 = $360,350
Now the part the invoice does not show. If commission averaged an illustrative 10% of premium, the broker earned 357,000 × 10% = $35,700 from inside the $357,000. That money is already in the total. Adding it again would report $396,050 and overstate the program by 10% of premium.
The same trap works with taxes. If someone enters the $2,850 tax as a fee and also computes it from the E&S premium, the total becomes $363,200 and the owner gets the wrong number.
How do you read an invoice without double counting?
Read it in three passes.
- Premiums only. Check each one against the policy's declarations page.
- The tax line. In Arizona it should equal 3% of the E&S premium plus any taxable policy or broker fees, with the stamping fee left out.
- Everything else. Policy fees, broker fees, stamping fees, inspection fees.
The total due should equal premium plus tax plus fees. If it does not, something is missing or duplicated. All three passes feed the risk transfer part of a contractor's total cost of risk.
Why does compensation transparency matter?
Two brokers can quote the same coverage at different prices partly because they are paid differently. One may take a higher commission inside the premium; another may take a lower commission plus a fee. Comparing only premiums hides that.
A contractor can reasonably ask every broker for a written statement of total compensation on each line: the commission rate or amount, any fee, and whether the broker receives contingent commission from the carriers it uses. That disclosure does not lower any number by itself. It makes the whole price visible, so brokers are compared on what they actually cost. The outgrown your agent guide covers what else to ask.
How each premium is built before any of this rides on top is covered in how insurance premium is built.
Quick answers
How much commission does an insurance broker make?
It varies by line, carrier and account, and it is built into the premium, so it rarely appears on an invoice. The reliable way to know is to ask the broker for total compensation on each line in writing.
Can an insurance broker charge a fee in Arizona?
Yes, with conditions. Surplus lines brokers must disclose any service fee and get written agreement before placing coverage, and the 3% tax applies to that fee (A.R.S. § 20-410). Arizona's general producer fee rule, A.R.S. § 20-465, excludes commercial insurance, so commercial fees rest on the written agreement.
What is contingent commission?
A bonus an insurer pays a broker based on the profitability or volume of all the business that broker placed with it. It does not appear on the client's invoice, which is why many buyers ask for it to be disclosed.
- Contingent commission
- A bonus an insurer pays a broker based on the profitability or volume of the business that broker placed with it. It does not appear on the client's invoice.
- Surplus lines tax
- A state tax on surplus lines premium, collected from the insured by the broker. In Arizona it is 3% of gross premium including policy fees, excluding stamping fees (A.R.S. § 20-416).
- Stamping fee
- A filing fee charged on surplus lines policies by the association that processes them for the state. In Arizona it is billed separately and is not subject to the surplus lines tax.
- A.R.S. § 20-465, Fees; insurance producers · Arizona State Legislature
- A.R.S. § 20-410, Validity of surplus lines insurance; disclosure; policy fees · Arizona State Legislature
- A.R.S. § 20-416, Tax on surplus lines · Arizona State Legislature
- Contingent commission (definition) · IRMI
Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.