Loss development factors (LDFs) explained

In short

A loss development factor (LDF) is a multiplier that carries today's incurred losses to their expected final, or ultimate, cost. Incurred losses keep growing after a loss run is printed, and the LDF measures how much, ideally from the same policy years valued at different dates.

A loss run is a snapshot. Read the same claims a year later and the incurred total is usually higher, even though nothing new happened. The claims you already had simply got more expensive. That growth is called loss development, and the tool for measuring it is the loss development factor.

Why do incurred losses grow?

Incurred losses are paid plus reserves, and reserves are estimates. They grow for four main reasons:

  1. Reserves get revised. Treatment unfolds, a surgery is added, a worker does not return to work when expected, and the adjuster raises the reserve.
  2. Claims are reported late. Some injuries in a policy year have not been reported when the run is printed. Actuaries call the allowance for these, plus future growth on known claims, IBNR: incurred but not reported.
  3. Claims reopen. A closed claim comes back when a condition recurs or a dispute starts.
  4. Legal and adjusting costs build. Attorney involvement adds defense and adjustment expense tied to the claim.

So the incurred figure on today's loss run is not what those years will finally cost. The final cost, once every claim is settled and closed, is the ultimate loss.

What is a loss development factor?

A loss development factor (LDF) is the multiplier that carries a current incurred figure to its expected ultimate. If a year's claims stand at $80,000 today and the factor for a year that age is 1.20, the expected ultimate is 80,000 × 1.20 = $96,000.

Factors are larger for young years, because most of their growth is still ahead, and for long-tailed lines like workers' comp, where claims can stay open for years. They shrink toward 1.00 as a year ages and its claims close.

How is an LDF calculated? The loss triangle

Actuaries measure development with a loss triangle. Each row is a policy year. Each column is an age: 12 months after the year began, 24 months, 36 months. Each cell holds that year's total incurred at that age. The oldest year has the most cells and the newest has one, so the filled cells form a triangle.

A worked example with illustrative numbers. A contractor's workers' comp runs were valued each February 1:

  • Policy year A: $100,000 at 12 months, $120,000 at 24 months, $126,000 at 36 months.
  • Policy year B: $100,000 at 12 months, $110,000 at 24 months.
  • Policy year C: $80,000 at 12 months.

Step 1, age-to-age factors (also called link ratios), later age divided by earlier age:

  • Year A, 12 to 24 months: 120,000 ÷ 100,000 = 1.20
  • Year B, 12 to 24 months: 110,000 ÷ 100,000 = 1.10
  • Year A, 24 to 36 months: 126,000 ÷ 120,000 = 1.05

Step 2, select one factor per step. A common choice is the volume-weighted average, which lets bigger years count more: for 12 to 24 months, (120,000 + 110,000) ÷ (100,000 + 100,000) = 1.15. For 24 to 36 months only Year A has data, so 1.05.

Step 3, add a tail factor for development beyond the oldest age. Workers' comp keeps developing past 36 months, so an actuary would normally supply one. With nothing on file, this example uses 1.00, which means "no further growth assumed," and that should be said out loud.

Step 4, multiply the factors into cumulative factors to ultimate:

  • At 36 months: 1.00
  • At 24 months: 1.05 × 1.00 = 1.05
  • At 12 months: 1.15 × 1.05 × 1.00 = 1.208

Step 5, develop each year from where it stands today:

  • Year A: 126,000 × 1.00 = $126,000
  • Year B: 110,000 × 1.05 = $115,500
  • Year C: 80,000 × 1.208 = $96,640
  • Total ultimate: $338,140, against $316,000 on today's loss run

The loss run understates these three years by 338,140 − 316,000 = $22,140, about 7%. Notice that most of it sits in the two youngest years. That is the age bias every loss run carries: new years look cheap because their story is unfinished.

This is the chain-ladder, or development, technique taught in the Casualty Actuarial Society's basic reserving text. Its core assumption is that your claims will keep developing the way they have in the past.

Where should the factor come from?

The best source is your own history: the same policy years valued at two or more dates, about twelve months apart. Two valuations of the same years are worth more to a forecast than five years valued once, because only the pair shows how fast your claims grow. Ask carriers for "five years of loss runs valued now and as of twelve months ago."

An actuary's study or a carrier's factors are the next best source. A factor borrowed from industry tables without saying so is a guess. It will be too high for a contractor that reports quickly, reserves accurately and closes claims, and too low for one carrying old open claims.

Two warnings. A factor below 1.00 is possible (claims close for less than reserved, recoveries arrive) but on a young year it more often means reserves were cut too early. And an LDF develops claims that already happened. It is not a forecast of next year's claims; that is the loss pick.

Why does this matter to a contractor?

Developed losses are what turn a loss-run total into a cost you can plan against. They decide whether a deductible or SIR is really saving money, and they are what an underwriter quietly does to your loss runs before quoting. Contractors that report injuries in days and close claims quickly develop less, and their factors show it.

Quick answers

What is a good loss development factor?

There is no single good number. It depends on the line, the age of the year and how the claims are handled; a factor near 1.00 is normal for an old, mostly closed year and a much higher one is normal for a young workers' comp year.

What does IBNR mean?

Incurred but not reported: the allowance for claims that have happened but are not yet on the loss run, often combined with expected growth on known claims.

What is a tail factor?

A factor that carries losses from the oldest age in the triangle to ultimate, for development the triangle cannot yet see. It matters most on workers' comp, where claims can stay open for years.

Terms in this entry
Loss development factor (LDF)
A multiplier that carries current incurred losses to their expected ultimate cost, measured from how past years grew between valuations.
IBNR (incurred but not reported)
An allowance for claims that have happened but are not yet reported, often combined with expected growth on known claims.
Incurred losses
Paid losses plus reserves on reported claims, as of a valuation date. The figure underwriters and the experience mod use.
Loss run
A carrier's claim-by-claim history for a policy, showing dates, status, paid and reserved amounts, all as of one valuation date.
Sources and standards
  1. Loss development factor · IRMI
  2. Estimating Unpaid Claims Using Basic Techniques (Friedland) · Casualty Actuarial Society
  3. Friedland Chapter 7: Development Technique (worked recreation) · chainladder-python project

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent