What moves the experience mod

In short

The experience mod moves mostly on how many claims you have, whether they stay medical-only, and how they are valued when the carrier reports them. It uses three completed policy years and skips the most recent one, so an injury this year first reaches your premium about two renewals from now and then stays for three.

Why does frequency move the mod more than severity?

The experience mod formula counts the first dollars of every claim, up to the split point, in full and discounts the rest. A claim smaller than the split point is entirely primary loss, so it lands on the mod at full weight. Ten small claims therefore push the mod harder than one large claim of the same total.

For an owner, that changes the prevention agenda. The number to manage first is the count of claims, and among them the lost-time claims. Severity still matters to the injured worker, to your retention and to your other costs, but it is the part of the mod the formula deliberately softens.

Which years count in my experience mod?

The experience period is generally three years of payroll and loss data, and it is set by the rating effective date, the date the new mod takes effect (normally your workers' comp renewal date). NCCI's rule is that a policy is included if it started no less than 21 months and no more than 57 months before the rating effective date. In practice that means the three completed policy years before the current one.

The policy you are in now is left out, because the mod is calculated during that policy, generally 60 to 90 days before the rating date, and carriers are not required to report a policy's data until 18 months after it begins. NCCI's own example: a mod effective Jan 1, 2026 uses policies that began Jan 1, 2022, 2023 and 2024.

When does an injury reach my premium?

Follow one injury through a contractor with a Feb 1 renewal. It happens in June 2026, inside the policy that began Feb 1, 2026.

  1. Feb 1, 2027 renewal: the mod uses policies beginning Feb 2023, 2024 and 2025. The June 2026 claim is not in it.
  2. Aug 1, 2027: 18 months after the policy began, the carrier reports that year's claims to NCCI at their value on that date.
  3. Feb 1, 2028 renewal: the mod uses 2024, 2025 and 2026. The claim enters.
  4. Feb 1, 2029 and Feb 1, 2030: the claim stays in, updated at later reports.
  5. Feb 1, 2031: the 2026 policy drops out. The claim is gone.

So every injury is a four-year bill: this year's direct and indirect costs, then three years of mod. The same arithmetic runs in reverse. Safety work done this year cannot lower the mod at the next renewal, only the one after it, and then for three years in a row. Anyone promising a lower mod at your next renewal from this year's improvements is promising something the plan does not allow.

How do reserves and valuation dates affect the mod?

The mod uses each claim's incurred value, which is the amount paid so far plus the carrier's reserve for what it still expects to pay, as of the date the carrier reports it. A claim that is closed by then enters at its final paid amount. A claim that is still open enters at paid plus reserve.

That makes open claims worth attention. A reserve set high early on and never revisited inflates the mod for as long as the claim sits in the window. You cannot set reserves, but you can ask the adjuster, ahead of the reporting date, for each open claim's reserve rationale and closure plan. Your loss runs show where each claim stands.

Does reporting speed matter?

Yes, and it is one of the few levers with published numbers behind it. NCCI studied lost-time claims by how long they took to be reported and found that median claim cost was lowest for claims reported in weeks one and two, then rose by about 35% for claims reported in week three relative to week two, with a further increase in week four. NCCI is careful that this is a correlation, not proof that the delay caused the cost; it also found more attorney involvement and a larger share of wage-replacement cost among late-reported claims.

Arizona sets its own deadline: under A.R.S. § 23-908(G), an employer must report to its carrier and the Industrial Commission within ten days after receiving notice of an accident. The first 72 hours of a claim guide covers the practical steps.

How much can medical-only claims and return to work change it?

A lot. Under NCCI's Experience Rating Adjustment, which Arizona applies by statute, a medical-only claim enters the mod at 30% of its value. A claim becomes lost-time once wage replacement is paid. Keeping an injured worker on the job in modified duty is often what keeps a claim medical-only.

An illustration, using the teaching values from the formula entry (denominator $150,000, fixed numerator part $106,000; not NCCI's values):

  1. Three lost-time claims of $20,000: primary 60,000. Mod = (60,000 + 106,000) ÷ 150,000 = 1.107.
  2. The same three kept medical-only: primary 3 × 20,000 × 0.30 = 18,000. Mod = (18,000 + 106,000) ÷ 150,000 = 0.827.
  3. Difference: 0.280 of mod. On an illustrative manual premium of $150,000, that is 0.280 × 150,000 = $42,000 a year, for each of the three years the claims sit in the window.

The levers, in order of weight:

  • Fewer claims, especially lost-time claims.
  • Claims kept medical-only through prompt care and return to work.
  • Claims reported within days, not weeks.
  • Open claims reviewed and closed, where they can honestly be closed, before the carrier reports them.

Quick answers

How long does a workers' comp claim stay on my experience mod?

Generally three ratings. A claim enters at the second renewal after the policy year it happened in and drops out when that year leaves the three-year experience period.

Why didn't my mod go down after a year with no injuries?

The mod skips the policy year you are in when it is calculated. A clean year first shows up at the renewal after next, and older years with claims may still be in the window.

Does closing a claim lower my experience mod?

It can. The mod uses paid plus reserve at the reporting date, so a claim closed for less than its reserve before the carrier reports it enters at a lower value.

Terms in this entry
Experience period
The policy years used in an experience mod, generally the three completed years before the current policy. The policy in force when the mod is calculated is left out.
Incurred losses
Paid losses plus reserves on reported claims, as of a valuation date. The figure underwriters and the experience mod use.
Experience Rating Adjustment (ERA)
NCCI's rule that counts only 30% of a medical-only claim in the experience mod, a 70% reduction. Arizona applies it by statute.
Sources and standards
  1. ABCs of Experience Rating · NCCI
  2. The Relationship Between Accident Report Lag and Claim Cost in Workers Compensation Insurance · NCCI
  3. A.R.S. § 23-908, Reports of injuries · Arizona State Legislature
  4. A.R.S. § 23-963.01, Deductible coverage; medical-only losses · Arizona State Legislature

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
Workers' comp and the experience modThe experience mod formulaThe experience mod compares a contractor's actual workers' comp losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for its size and class mix.Workers' comp and the experience modReturn-to-work programs for contractorsA return-to-work program brings an injured employee back to suitable modified or light duty as soon as their doctor allows.Retention and loss financingLoss runs: how to read oneA loss run is your insurance carrier's claim-by-claim history for a policy: each claim's dates, status, amount paid and amount still reserved, all as of one valuation date.Workers' comp and the experience modThe NCCI experience rating worksheetThe NCCI experience rating worksheet is the document that shows how your experience mod was calculated: payroll and expected losses by class, every claim with its primary and excess value, the rating values, and the final mod.Cost of riskIndirect cost of workplace injuriesThe indirect cost of an injury is everything it costs the business beyond the claim itself, such as lost work time, overtime, replacement and retraining, supervisor time and damaged property.Resources · 5 min guideWhat to do after a workplace injury: the first 72 hoursWhat happens right after an injury shapes what that claim will cost. Here's how to get it right.Resources · 5 min guideHow the experience mod works for contractorsWhat the mod is, why one claim rides on it for years, and the parts an owner can actually move.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent