Incident investigation and root cause analysis

In short

An incident investigation finds out why an injury or near miss happened so it does not happen again. OSHA's guidance uses four steps (preserve and document the scene, collect information, determine root causes, implement corrective actions) and warns against stopping at "the worker was careless."

What is an incident investigation?

An incident investigation is a structured look at an injury, illness, property loss or near miss to learn why it happened and what will stop it from happening again. OSHA prefers the word incident to accident, because nearly every workplace injury is preventable, and "accident" suggests nothing could have been done.

A near miss is an event that could have hurt someone but did not: a load that slipped and landed clear, a worker who stepped off an unguarded edge onto a lower roof without injury. Near misses have the same causes as injuries and cost nothing to learn from, which makes them the best investigations a company can run.

What is a root cause?

Every incident has an immediate cause and one or more root causes.

  • The immediate cause is what happened at the moment: the ladder slid, the trench wall fell, the worker touched a live wire.
  • A root cause is the management, planning, design or training failure that let the immediate cause exist: no one checked the ladder footing because no one was assigned to, the trench was dug without a competent person's inspection because the schedule was tight, the circuit was not locked out because the procedure was never written.

Root cause analysis is the discipline of tracing back from the first to the second. OSHA's guidance is direct: conclusions like "the worker was careless" or "the procedure was not followed" are where an investigation should keep going, not where it should stop.

What are the four steps?

OSHA's guide for employers lays out a four-step systems approach:

  1. Preserve and document the scene. Secure the area, take photos and video, sketch the layout, and record who, when and where before anything is moved.
  2. Collect information. Interview the injured worker, witnesses and supervisors promptly, one at a time. Gather records: training files, inspection logs, equipment manuals, the job hazard analysis, the schedule.
  3. Determine root causes. Ask why, then ask why again, until you reach something the company controls: a program, a process, a resource, a decision.
  4. Implement corrective actions. Fix the root causes, assign an owner and a date for each fix, and check later that it worked.

Investigations work best as a small team: the supervisor who knows the work, a worker who does it, and someone from management with authority to change things. The aim is to find causes, not fault. People hide facts from an investigation that is hunting for someone to blame.

A worked example: a fall from a ladder

Illustrative event. A carpenter falls from a 10-foot stepladder at 2:00 pm on a Tuesday, breaks a wrist and is admitted to the hospital overnight.

The clocks start first:

  • In-patient hospitalization: report to OSHA within 24 hours, so by 2:00 pm Wednesday.
  • OSHA 300 log: enter the recordable case within 7 calendar days of learning of it, so by the following Tuesday.

Then the "why" chain:

  1. Why did he fall? He was standing on the top cap of the ladder, which shifted.
  2. Why the top cap? The ladder was too short to reach the work from a safe step.
  3. Why that ladder? It was the tallest one on the truck.
  4. Why only one ladder size? The job's equipment list was copied from a previous single-story job.
  5. Why was the list not checked? No one reviews equipment against the work during pre-job planning.

The root cause is a planning gap, not a careless worker. Compare two corrective actions. "Remind the crew not to stand on the top cap" costs nothing and changes little. Adding an equipment check to pre-job planning, and buying two taller ladders or a rolling platform for this job (illustrative cost: 2 × $450 = $900), removes the condition that caused the fall. Better fixes sit higher on the hierarchy of controls: elimination, substitution and engineering controls first, then administrative controls and personal protective equipment last.

What makes corrective actions work?

  • Each action addresses a root cause, not only the immediate cause.
  • Each has a named owner and a due date.
  • Someone follows up to confirm the fix was made and is holding.
  • Lessons are shared with other crews doing similar work.

How does investigation connect to cost?

Every injury repeats unless its cause is removed, and repeats are what drive frequency, the factor that tends to move the experience mod most. Each repeat also carries uninsured costs, covered in the indirect cost of injuries. A good investigation file supports the claim itself, helps answer underwriter questions about specific losses on the loss runs, and feeds the company's risk register. The first steps after an injury, including reporting the claim, are covered in the first 72 hours of a claim.

Quick answers

What is the difference between an immediate cause and a root cause?

The immediate cause is what happened at the moment of the incident, such as a ladder sliding. The root cause is the management, planning or training gap that allowed it, such as no one assigning the right ladder for the job.

Should near misses be investigated?

Yes. OSHA encourages employers to investigate near misses as well as injuries, because they share the same causes and can be fixed before anyone is hurt.

What are OSHA's four steps of incident investigation?

Preserve and document the scene, collect information, determine root causes, and implement corrective actions. OSHA describes them in its 2015 guide for employers.

Terms in this entry
Root cause analysis
Tracing an incident back past its immediate cause to the management, planning or training gap that allowed it, usually by asking why repeatedly.
Recordable case
A work-related injury or illness that results in death, days away, restricted work or transfer, medical treatment beyond first aid, loss of consciousness, or a significant diagnosed condition. It must go on the OSHA 300 log.
Sources and standards
  1. Incident Investigation · OSHA
  2. Incident [Accident] Investigations: A Guide for Employers · OSHA
  3. Hierarchy of Controls · NIOSH / CDC
  4. 29 CFR Part 1904: Recording and Reporting Occupational Injuries and Illnesses · eCFR (National Archives)

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library
Safety and operationsOSHA recordkeeping and the 300 logUnder 29 CFR 1904, a contractor with more than 10 employees during the prior year must record work-related injuries that meet OSHA's recording criteria on the OSHA 300 log within 7 calendar days, back each one with a 301 report, and post the 300A annual summary from Feb 1 to Apr 30.Workers' comp and the experience modWhat moves the experience modThe experience mod moves mostly on how many claims you have, whether they stay medical-only, and how they are valued when the carrier reports them.Cost of riskIndirect cost of workplace injuriesThe indirect cost of an injury is everything it costs the business beyond the claim itself, such as lost work time, overtime, replacement and retraining, supervisor time and damaged property.The risk management processRisk register and risk appetiteA risk register lists each risk a business faces with its score before and after controls, the technique chosen, a named owner and a review date.Retention and loss financingLoss runs: how to read oneA loss run is your insurance carrier's claim-by-claim history for a policy: each claim's dates, status, amount paid and amount still reserved, all as of one valuation date.Resources · 5 min guideWhat to do after a workplace injury: the first 72 hoursWhat happens right after an injury shapes what that claim will cost. Here's how to get it right.Resources · 5 min guideWhat insurance really costs a contractor: the hidden billThe premium is the smallest honest number in your business. Here's where the rest of the bill hides, and why it matters to your net operating income.

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent