Risk baseline and verified savings

In short

A risk baseline is a frozen, dated record of a business's starting cost of risk, used as the yardstick for every later improvement. A verified saving is one backed by a third-party document, such as a premium audit statement, renewal quote or experience mod worksheet; projections are estimates and should always be reported separately.

What is a risk baseline?

A risk baseline is a frozen record of where a business started: its total cost of risk, how that total breaks down, its cost of risk per $1,000 of revenue, and the revenue it was measured on, all as of a stated date. Every later claim of improvement is measured against it.

The "as of" date is the period the numbers describe, usually the end of the last full fiscal year, not the day someone typed them in.

Why does the baseline have to stay frozen?

Inputs change. A controller finds that revenue was really $12,500,000, not $12,000,000. A loss gets re-reserved. Those corrections are real and should be recorded, each with a reason. But the baseline itself does not move.

Here is why, with illustrative numbers. A contractor's baseline is $617,950 of cost of risk on $12,000,000 of revenue, or $51.50 per $1,000. Two months later revenue is corrected to $12,500,000. The current view becomes 617,950 ÷ 12,500,000 × 1,000 = $49.44. If the baseline were simply edited, the $2.06 drop would look like a saving. It is not. It is a correction. Keeping the baseline fixed, and recording corrections separately with their reasons, keeps the two from blurring.

That also means the inputs should be right before the baseline is set. The best practice is to read the totals aloud with the owner, fix anything they dispute, and only then lock it. A starting point the owner agreed to is one they will trust later.

Projected savings vs verified savings

Two kinds of savings numbers exist, and they should never be added together.

  • A projected saving (or estimated saving) is arithmetic on the business's own inputs: if minor injuries fall from six to three, here is what that should be worth. It is a forecast.
  • A verified saving is an amount a document shows actually happened: an audit statement, a renewal quote, a mod worksheet.

Report them separately. An owner should always be able to answer "how much have we actually saved?" with a number that has a document behind it.

Projections deserve plain caveats too. A simple projection takes each saving in full from the year it starts, holds revenue and payroll flat, and leaves out what the business spends to get there. Say so. A saving tied to the experience mod should not be promised for the next renewal, because NCCI generally builds the mod from three years of data and excludes the current policy. Lead with the conservative figure.

What counts as proof?

Proof is a document from someone other than the business or its advisor:

  • A premium audit statement showing what the carrier actually charged
  • A policy endorsement showing a credit or change
  • A binder or renewal quote showing the bound premium and credits
  • The experience mod worksheet the rating bureau issued
  • A loss run or closed claim valued after the fact
  • An invoice showing a fee or cost that fell
  • Payroll records by class code

What does not count: a vendor's claimed result, a projection, an email that says "should be about," or the owner's sense that things are better.

A worked example (illustrative numbers)

A contractor paid $200,000 last year to subcontractors who could not show valid workers' comp coverage. At audit, carriers commonly treat payments like these as payroll and charge premium on them. At an illustrative $8.00 per $100 class rate and a 1.15 mod, the estimated cost of that gap is 200,000 ÷ 100 × 8.00 × 1.15 = $18,400 a year.

The business adopts a rule: no current certificate of insurance, no start. A year later the audit statement arrives.

  1. $160,000 of the $200,000 is now backed by valid certificates and is not charged.
  2. $40,000 is still uncovered and is charged.
  3. Verified saving: 160,000 ÷ 100 × 8.00 × 1.15 = $14,720.
  4. Against the estimate: 14,720 − 18,400 = −$3,680, a miss, exactly the charge on the $40,000 still uncovered.

Record the miss as plainly as a beat. It says the rule held for 80% of the old gap, and it names the next piece of work. A miss explained that way builds more trust than a vague "we saved a lot."

"My premium still went up"

Premium has four moving parts: exposure (payroll, sales, vehicles), rate (set by the bureau and carrier), the experience mod (built from the business's own claims) and market and placement. Break a change into those parts before judging it.

An illustrative renewal: payroll grows from $3,000,000 to $3,400,000, the class rate stays at $5.00 per $100, and the mod falls from 1.15 to 1.10.

  • Last year: 3,000,000 ÷ 100 × 5.00 × 1.15 = $172,500
  • This year: 3,400,000 ÷ 100 × 5.00 × 1.10 = $187,000
  • Exposure effect: 400,000 ÷ 100 × 5.00 × 1.15 = +$23,000
  • Mod effect: 170,000 × (1.10 − 1.15) = −$8,500
  • Check: 23,000 − 8,500 = +$14,500

The premium rose because the business grew 13%. Per $100 of payroll, it fell from $5.75 to $5.50. The safety work showed up; growth hid it. This is why rates, not dollar totals, are the fair scorecard.

A program measured this way fits on one page: the cost of risk rate at baseline, the target rate, and verified savings to date. Everything else is detail behind those three. The same verified documents also make the strongest renewal submission, which is why they are gathered on the insurance renewal timeline. For an owner's guide to the same idea, see verified savings.

Quick answers

What is the difference between projected and verified savings?

A projected saving is a forecast built from the business's own inputs. A verified saving is an amount a document, such as an audit statement, endorsement or mod worksheet, shows actually happened. The two should be reported separately and never added together.

Why did my premium go up if our safety improved?

Premium moves with exposure, rates, the experience mod and the market. If payroll grew, premium can rise even while the mod falls; compare premium per $100 of payroll to see the improvement.

Can a risk baseline be changed later?

It should not be. Corrections to inputs should be recorded separately, with a reason, so a correction is never mistaken for a saving.

Terms in this entry
Risk baseline
A frozen, dated record of a business's starting cost of risk, used as the yardstick for every later improvement.
Verified savings
Savings backed by a third-party document, such as a premium audit statement, renewal quote or experience mod worksheet, as opposed to a projection.
Premium audit
The carrier's review of actual payroll by class after a policy ends. It settles the premium as additional premium owed or return premium refunded.
Experience mod (EMR)
A multiplier on workers' comp premium comparing your actual losses over three prior policy years with the losses expected for your size and class mix. 1.00 is average; above it is a debit, below it a credit.
Certificate of insurance (COI)
A one-page summary, usually on the ACORD 25 form, that shows a policyholder's insurers, policy numbers, dates and limits. It is evidence of coverage on the day it was issued, not a policy, and it grants the holder no rights.
Sources and standards
  1. ABCs of Experience Rating · NCCI
  2. Cost of Risk (COR) definition · IRMI

Worked examples use illustrative numbers unless a source is named. This entry explains general concepts; it isn't legal, tax or coverage advice for a specific policy or contract.

Brandon Junkin
Brandon Junkin, Founder of Frost

I built Frost, the risk management platform approved insurance agents use to run contractor risk programs. Seven years in IT taught me to fix the cause, not the symptom. More about Frost

Related in the Library

Want this run for your company?

Approved Frost agents deliver full-service fractional risk management on Frost: your total cost of risk, a plan with owners and documented savings, at a fraction of the cost of a risk department.

Find an approved agent